Virtual.ray,
You're correct, there is another tube for the reverb in addition to the 4 12AX7s. It's a 12 something or other but I didn't list that one because I didn't believe it to be part of the problem.
I could do the swap thing but I don't think I'd be able to get tubes with close enough specs to the originals. They were made by GE and I'm pretty sure they don't make 'em anymore. I might be able to get one matched set though and swap one pair at a time.
Daddy-O,
Good suggestion about just doing the 6L6s. I haven't called Mojotone yet, but I will.
Foo,
The prices that I found without a whole lot of digging were around $300 to replace all 8. The 6L6s are pretty expensive.
The sound isn't really bad at low volumes when playing clean. When I turn up though, there's a noticible loss of power over what this amp did when it was new. If I start driving it to distortion the, sound is kind of broken, like a cheap distortion stomp box. Even clean, the louder I go the worse the sound gets. This amp didn't used to do that.
Since these tubes have seen 20 years of action, I figure they've done their job and deserve retirement.
I seriously considered just buying a new head and using this one as a back up. But, I dont think a new head would really sound any better than this one, if it was working right. It really is a nice amp.