Quiet computers

  • Thread starter Thread starter dobro
  • Start date Start date
I was looking at isobox and isomac a little while ago ...
here's another cool box
http://www.vexers.se/en/indexe.htm
really expensive, though ... I would imagine.

also, here's a good site with lots of info on getting rid of PC noise ...
http://home.swipnet.se/tr/silence.html#methods

Those iso boxes are hard to find ... and expensive. It seems to me that there's a niche out there for someone who is good at woodworking. There's lots of people recording with DAWs these days. Hmm...
 
The big problem with isoboxes, as I've learned to my pain and detriment, is that no matter how good the isolation of the box proper might be: you still have to cool it. And if the cooling airflow is noisy, what was the point? I just this very evening put a Raxxess Isoraxx 14-space hushbox on the truck to return to the vendor. My finding was that the box was *noisier* than the equipment I was putting into it!

Now, there are some spectacularly noisy computers out there, to be sure, and those would indeed be helped by that box. But the big problem with the Raxxess box was that the air handling system inside it made just as much noise as a production computer case. No win- in fact, as lose, compared to a modified computer with properly-tuned cooling.

My conclusion is as follows: you have to move air to dissipate heat and keep modern high-tech equipment alive. This can be attacked by moving the air more slowly (which implies a larger aperture for the air to move through), or by moving it into a space that you aren't in (sticking the machinery in another room, or venting the "hushbox" into a separate space from the area occupied by your mics). Or, as I've decided to employ, you can move less air more efficiently, and decouple mechanical noise sources from the environment in other mechanical ways.

Now that I've had a chance to work with this a bit, I find myslef tending to reduce fan speeds to the minimum that can support survivable cooling, and to add mass and damping to enclosure materials. The sheetmetal cases for most PCs, and more than a few professional studio pieces, are often large unsupported sheet metal spans with no damping... These will ring like *bells*. Think of the exterior sides as 19" by 19" speaker cones with your disk drive as thge voice coil! A small amount of damping can keep acoustical energy from crossing the barrier presented by the case (by killing resonances), and adding mass can alter the resonant frequencies: often enough to get a problem piece of gear to hide in the HVAC noise of the room.

Turbulent airflow noise, the "whoosh" of most PCs, can be dealt with by reducing the airflow to the minimum necessary to keep it alive (and adding internal baffling to focus that airflow to where it does the most good, over the heatsinks and SIMMs). Mechanical vibrations, the pitched "whine", can most effectively be dealt with by decoupling (mounting the source on compliant isolators, like rubber pucks to mount a disk drive carrier) and by adding mass and damping to detune and reduce the Q of any resonances.

Some whines are airflow-related, like the small-diameter CPU cooler fans that often operate in pretty much stalled air (and whine as a result of their blades encountering their own turbulence). For those, the best that can be done is to reduce the fan speed to the point that the blades aren't stalled. They are probably more efficient as coolers in that case as well...

The more you pay for a hushbox, the better designed the cooling mechanism will likely be, and the better your results. However, ultimately you're putting a box with fans inside a box with fans. I was disappointed with my low-end hushbox experience, but in retrospect I should have known better! There ain't no such thing as a free lunch.
 
Hey, Big Kahuna- thanks very much for that link to the cooling/noise overview article! I hadn't encountered that one before, and it is a very good read- lots of things to think about.

My new Soundchaser rackmount DAW is sitting downstairs now, burning in. I've cranked back on several of the fan speeds, and have thermocouples installed on the CPU heatsink adjacent to the die, the disk drives, and so on to directly monitor the process. It was decently quiet out of the box, as advertised, but I believe that it can be made better yet by optimizing the airflow. A couple of days of tuning and tweeking and it'll be ready to deploy, and I think that I can live with it. I may also install a front panel power switch just for the Yamaha CD-RW drive, which makes some noise even when no disk is mounted (it has a teeny little 30mm cooling fan just for the spindle motor). I put that drive on its own controller just so that I could power cycle it, hopefully without wedging the box... I've put about 3lb of Dynamat onto the various sheetmetal surfaces, most notably the top and bottom panels of the case. Each tweeks yields just a little more improvement.

If anybody actually tries any of the other commercially-available isobox products, please post back here with your experiences. I'd love to know about any success stories.
 
I'd just like to add a quick point about the silentdrive enclosure..

I had one for my new daw i built last year... (not so new then...) anyway, i had IBM 60GXP drives (if memory serves)

These silentdrive thingies aren't really good at keeping the drive's cool. After 20 minutes, the whole hard disk stopped working.... after panicing like crazy (easily done...) i removed the silentdrive enclosure... let the HD cool down, and it worked fine again...

So... don't bother with those silent drive enclosures... the hard disk is pretty much whisper quiet for me anyway :)

Cheers..

R
 
Back
Top