pre- amp A/b
TomBo777 said:
I thought i'd use the stereo pre for the inputs from the Synths unless I can get at least Mackie quality Pre amps on the DAW. I like the Meek stuff and I don't believe I have the ears to hear the sonic character between mid priced pre amps (or even higher priced ones for that matter). I'm kinda strange that way. I live in Las Vegas where there are dozens of supposedly really good italian resturants. I have one I love, for years, and no interest in even trying the others...unless Carluccios goes out of business.
Im not that much of a "micro" listener or mixer in these years. I have friends who will EQ and mess with a single track for hours. I'm not that anal, thank Goodness. In fact he is a Pro Tools MAC guy and we always debate the PC/MAc issue.
I have no desire to change formats now. I have been on the PC platform with Cakewalk since the first DOS version and I especially don't care for anything propietary...like TDM. I have a ton of Direct X plug ins, softsynths and all the VST softsysnths and stuff as well...Nah..No Pro Tools for me in this lifetime. The SOnar 4 Producer Package is so good now I can't see how anything can be much better. I also have and used Nuendo 1.5. Always went back to the familiar.
I have friends with a PC based Neundo system and another as mentioned with The BIg boy Pro Tools set up on a MAC in his "floating Studio". This guy is as anal as they come with his special caulking for his totally isolated floating isolated basement studio. They both seem to work well. Both users are fast and obviously know their software. But Sonar has everthing I need and much much more with it's Loop recording and creating and softsynth technology. Besides Im getting $900 software for $179 on the up grade path.
I need to take a look at Fire face and a Mackie interface combo, otherwise its most likely the TAscam and a stereo Pre amp. Im one of the few who really have no issue with Mackie Pre amps for general use. Not vocals or Ac GTr.
I have Cubase SX and nice set of Waves plugs among others so I was only interested in front end.
I almost went down this road and even ordered an Avalon 737sp just to kill the debate in my mind. Sweetwater and everyone else has a back order so cancelled and a studio friend loaned me a UA 6176 which is a proper peice of
kit. History first:
1)I was happy tracking with my mackie1202 through the summing buss and into a 2496 till I read the summing buss and 60 feet of internal wire weren't helping things.
2) there was 20% improvement in top end using the VLZ to 24/96 m-audio card, joy !!
3) then I bought a light buld tube ( prosonus BlueTube DP) which sounds like
a modern mackie transparent IC pre with the tube not engaged. Tube in is good for effect but not vox and no roundin.
4) My friend bought
a Fire POD for band practice and tracking ( it did sound better than the mackie /M audio combo.
5) I went to buy the FirePod and changed at the last minute to the new Mackie 400F for repued better convertors and the New Onyx pre-amps.
6) the biggest gain was in the Mackie convertors over the 2496 audiophile and Delta 66 ( noticably darker and less tight, but an esoteric 5-6 % improvement) but the mackie doesn't have consumer line option so you'll
use up some pre's on your keyboards and POD among other things cause the +4 isn't hot enough ( glad I kept the1202 mixer with the 4 extra pre's to bump up my MS 2000 or any other keyboard you have)
7) now we could test the Pro kit A/B/C
a) UA6176 pre- vox, bass tracked to cubase with 4:1 compression and
3db reduction
b) Bluetube (tube off, clean) Renn. Waves Compressor with same reduction levels
c) Onyx with Renn, Waves compressor with same reduction.
I could not here the difference ( the UA is less harsh in sylbiss hi-eq) but its
so, so, so tiny
So it went pre to pre
a) UA 610b portion of the 6176
b) Bluetube ( tube off) trust me tube on is a fuzz box no rounding
c) Onyx
the UA pre is drivable and prints hotter, darker than both the Presonus and Onyx ( less harsh hi-eq....but this is esoterically slight)
The onyx was brighter and seems like maybe it might make nylon gut, strings click a little more. with bluetube being a hair less bright than onyx.
But, after everything got a little mild transparent compression in Waves it sounded ...well the same. I think thats fair as the nature of driven tubes in a
$1000 channel is that it does a little compression on its own.
I don't track drums so I couldn't tell you and it might show up more here.
All differences where so slight I spent many sessions returning to my Tannoy passives and scratching my head.
More testing with different mic's and Bass dirrect. Days of testing and wanting to love this big UA6176 and glowing on my desktop; well, not $2400 worth of love.
Now, changing mic's made tangable differences. The new 400F convertors also made a real difference in clarity, spend your money on a RME or Apogee
AD/DA box for gitter free line or your not gonna hear the very subtle diff. in pre's anyway....well before somebody ripps it MP3 ..ha ha
I'd spend my money on mic's and pluggins !!! And, for $2400 bucks you can
buy a lot of sonic variation ( Waves, UAD, a few dynamics , mic's and a couple of Condensor mics) These pluggs have harmonic saturation and analog sound modeled into them!
The proof is in the fact that if you go to the Univeral Audio web page they have demos A and B of they're LN1176 vintage conpressor and the womans vox is tracked through a Mackie 1604 VLZ .....why not a 610B pre or 110 pre.
and it sounds good.
If the performance isn't there no pre-amp will save it.!!
If you need a varitey of good mic's and pre's rent the space from
a professional studio after you've worked up all your tracks a home.
$400 will buy you a block of time, songs tracked in a good space ,
a demo of 15K worth of kit and education on how to mic up the thing your trying to record.
Here is a guy who has a dozen pre-amps, top flight mic's and experiance
placing them. Then bring it all home to your personal studio DAW and over dub your perfect tracks.. you with probably discover the perfect Grace 201
ribbon mic combination that does what you want and then save your money for that cause after I started borrowing this UA 6176 I started looking over $1000 mic 's to go with and then slapped myself.
Going to this board and asking opions before dropping $2400 is a shot in the dark. After you get baseline Mackie pre's or PreSonus firepod, or DMP 2
its like spending $700 on a good moutain bike verse $2500...4% better competitive advantage for 3 times the price.
I'll be giving
the UA 6176 and the Manely Refernce gold mic back and live happily with
the Onyx 400F and GT 55 Fet mic.
I'm gonna spend that money on a good Convolution reverb plug , AT4060 tube mic and an M-160 ribbon first. Things that make a differnce.