I'm a little away from the pre-upgrade decision so I'm really pleased to be following this post. For a beginner set up, I've been working with 2 DMP3's, an RNP and a Joemeek vc6q. It's a good balance of clean/color for a newbie.
Everything I've researched towards an upgrade matches what I'm reading here. The John Hardy sounds really clear, but very full and alive. The Great River MP-1NV is my favorite. Very warm and present. But most of what I do right now is blues and rock influenced, so that makes sense. The Grace is also very good, but my impression is that it isn't different enough from the sound I'm getting. This isn't based on a good a/b comparison, so, take my bias with a grain of salt. The Sytek gets a speacial nod. I've emailed the guy a couple of times and he's always helpful, always very responsive to my questions. He really seems to care about the quality of his product. That does count for something in my book.
As it stands, I'm saving up for
the Great River MP-2NV, with an open eye toward developments in other pres. I'm going to try very hard to a/b my final choices when the time comes.
As an aside, hey ebeam, I've tried the 3 mic drum recording. The drummer I work with really likes to control the flavor of his snare, so I always end up with a 4 mic setup. The funny thing is that we did a test cd of mic placement and pre's before recording seriously. Everytime we go back through the notes, he says, "Man, I really loved that one take..." one with a 3 mic mix! Go figure.