If it were me making this decision, I would purchase a synth/keyboard first such as the Motif or a Triton and consider a sampler later.....
I've thought about that also, about the Motif. But I can only afford One really good platform. Maybe, just maybe getting the Motif Rack later.
- The sampler will need a controller. You had mentioned
the Midiman Oxygen 8. 25 keys, USB interface (no standard midi ports from what I could find, no after touch (?). Basically designed for connection to computer to control soft synths. A keyboard such as the Motif would be a far better controller than the Oxygen 8, if you could even get the Oxygen 8 to work somehow via USB. Even a $600 Alesis QS6 would be far better than the Oxygen. And the 25 keys of the Oxygen would be very, very limiting to play on.
I thought that keyboard had everything. I rarely use more than one hand on the keys when programming sequences so the size was just to my advantage. I even read somewhere, it had aftertouch. I'll look into that after purchase.
- A Motif or Triton are in fact sample players in that the basis for the sound they create are from samples in ROM memory in the board. No need to load samples from an external source. Most of these samples are multisampled (individual samples over a range of octaves from the source instrument), so the resulting sound is as realistic as possible. If your looking for a good piano or Hammond B3 you can probable get it out of either of these boards or tweak/edit the sound a bit to your satisfaction.
I'll probably get the Motif Rack later on. But my main purpose for a sampler was to get out of the ordinary sounds. Sounds that aren't on every Rock/Pop album that come out. As you are stating in this next paragraph.
- I tend to use the sampler to add specialized accent sounds to a piece, and generally not as the fundamental instrument. These are sounds I absolutely can't derive from a synth such as vocal snipets, sound efx, etc. I find most of the time a synth is more than adequate for pianos, strings, orchestral sounds, etc.
- If you are auditioning sounds to fit a particular song, a synth will be much quicker to find sounds than loading sound sets in a sampler.
Precisly! Couldn't have said it better myself.
- The Motif as well as the Triton can be fit with expansion boards. You could essentially turn the Motif into a Virtual Analog synth or a vintage Yamaha DX-7.
That is something I really like to do, both the analog and the DX expansion. They sound really good, Yamaha also has a lot of experience with both these areas so it shouldn't sound that bad.
- Computer sequencing is great such as you are doing. Having the onboard sequencing capabiity in the Motif is good if you ever play outside the studio. Also as a quick sketchpad the on board sequencers are good.
What kind of sequencing program do you recomend. I'm using ProTools LE for the moment being!
************************************************
- What was your opinion of the sounds of the Motif when you tried it ? (Use a good set of headphones when auditioning a board, external amps and speakers and surroundings sometimes "color" the sound)
I tried both platforms with the same sets of headphone. I hated Triton. U've heard it all before on every single record to come out after 1998. And even doesn't sound any good. Motif on the other hand is a beautiful synth/sample playback tool which sounds amazing for being a synth. A negative side to the Motif is however that you're basicly stuck with the sounds as with any modern sample synth/workstation.
As I said, I'll probably get the Motif rack instead of the platform.
- Did the Motif seem to lack something which steered you towards the sampler?
Personal sounds, I like things that are personal and editable. So you could easely change the way things sound. And it didn't have all that many Percussive sounds. Just the basic drumkits. They sounded really good though, especially the POP and DnB kits.
-And what was the turn off about the Triton ?
Triton lacks dynamics in contrast to Motif for example. The Triton sounds flat and lifeless and I didn't find any patch that kinda stood out on its own. It's probably a nice workstation if you're into electronic music. But not if you like retro sounds like I do.
-I've played with both of these boards in the music store and they both sounded great. It would be a tough choice between the two. But I say again, I would purchase the synth before the rack sampler.
That would probably be a good choice for me too, but I've chosen to go for the Rack version of the Motif and get a really good sampler and a nice sequencing program for my computer.
The Motif 6 has all that you might say, but to what extent.