i really like both... i thought the chord sequence in Verion 11 got a bit repetitive. i was ready for a change when the sax solo came in, even something quite subtle would be nice.
Smokey Girl - i really couldn't tell if that was a full drum kit, or just some percussion... either way, it needs to be a lot louder. i think it'd carry the beat much better if it was louder. the sax lines are nice - have you tried anything but parallel harmonies? it'd sound cool if you left it as it was at the start, and then later in the song, developed it a bit more, with maybe the lower line moving down when the upper line was moving up. contrary motion, that's the ticket! - and was it meant to end so abruptly? i couldn't tell.