MOTU 828mkII vs. RME Fireface 800

[UnderTheGroove]

I am interested in upgrading my audio interface from my current M-Audio Delta 66 to a firewire unit. I need extra inputs and hope I’ll get an improvement in A/D converters. I’m looking at the MOTU 828mkII and the RME Fireface 800. Can anyone comment on these two units?

The RME is new so I know there won’t be many people with firsthand experience, but they have a solid reputation for converters (the 800 has the same converters as ADI-8) and drivers. It also has 4 pres, which could come in handy for extras. The downside is a street price of about $1450.

The 828 seems to get mixed opinions, but some people love it MOTU support is said to be horrible. The upside is a lower street price of about $750.

Would the converters on the Fireface make it worth the price difference? Are there any other things to consider?

Thanks,
UnderTheGroove


BTW - This is all for a mid level project studio. I’m getting a new computer soon for audio use running Sonar 3. I have a Great River MP2NV and Presonus MP20 for pres, so the pre quality of the interfaces is a minor consideration. I’m using Event 20/20bas monitors. I want firewire so I can eventually do some location recording with a laptop.

 

[ssscientist]

I have a Great River MP2NV and Presonus MP20 for pres, so the pre quality of the interfaces is a minor consideration. I’m using Event 20/20bas monitors. I want firewire so I can eventually do some location recording with a laptop.

You have answered your own question. For the price of the fireface you can get two 828mkII's and from what I've read once you get the drivers installed the things are pretty much bulletproof -- any lack of support from MOTU won't be a concern.