Mix check - constructive feedback welcome - encourged even

  • Thread starter Thread starter PorterhouseMusic
  • Start date Start date
PorterhouseMusic

PorterhouseMusic

Well-known member
I shared this track about 3 years ago when I finished recording it. It's an electric gtr instrumental. I wasn't super happy with the mix at the time but just let it ride. So I've asked an acquaintance to revisit it and put a new sheen on it. I'm already making notes in my head and will listen to it on a few different playback systems as time allows over the next couple of days. It's quite a bit different than the mix that I'd done. Sonically speaking - but also... I had the lead gtr washed in some verb and delay. This version is much drier.

I welcome all constructive feedback.

 
i like how the guitar sound has articulation to it.
nice and chewy.
i think i remember the original version of this,
but can't remember the mix...
but this one, i like the drier approach, it is more immediate, which matches the playing.

this would be easy to add vox.
you'd have to mute a few lead solo sections here and there, but then let those play thru when the vox would be silent.

good mix, like the snappy snare sound.
 
On my external computer speakers (Creative), the mix works well. I usually listen with those since it is a more likely set of speakers than my monitors.
 
On my external computer speakers (Creative), the mix works well. I usually listen with those since it is a more likely set of speakers than my monitors.
Thank you for the feedback - appreciated.
 
i like how the guitar sound has articulation to it.
nice and chewy.
i think i remember the original version of this,
but can't remember the mix...
but this one, i like the drier approach, it is more immediate, which matches the playing.

this would be easy to add vox.
you'd have to mute a few lead solo sections here and there, but then let those play thru when the vox would be silent.

good mix, like the snappy snare sound.
Thank you for giving this a listen. Popmann remixed this and sent it to me last night.

I'll consider adding some vocals. You mentioned that twice now:thumbs up:
 
I shared this track about 3 years ago when I finished recording it. It's an electric gtr instrumental. I wasn't super happy with the mix at the time but just let it ride. So I've asked an acquaintance to revisit it and put a new sheen on it. I'm already making notes in my head and will listen to it on a few different playback systems as time allows over the next couple of days. It's quite a bit different than the mix that I'd done. Sonically speaking - but also... I had the lead gtr washed in some verb and delay. This version is much drier.

I welcome all constructive feedback.


Awesome! I love this, great soloing, catchy and tasty licks, strong main riff, tight drums, what's not to love?
 
i like how the guitar sound has articulation to it.
nice and chewy.
i think i remember the original version of this,
but can't remember the mix...
but this one, i like the drier approach, it is more immediate, which matches the playing.

this would be easy to add vox.
you'd have to mute a few lead solo sections here and there, but then let those play thru when the vox would be silent.

good mix, like the snappy snare sound.
I have pretty much the same sentiment.
Lemme add this, you got a lot of Rush influence going on there. :D
 
@Eric V Thanks! Glad you dig it. Thanks for listening.

@RFR - Thanks for listening and commenting - it's helpful to the cause. Re: the Rush comment - I think it's certainly true that we are what we eat. :-) On the occasions that I listen to stuff I played on from yesteryear I sometimes hear my influences in my own playing, it's true.

@GONZO-X - those guitar parts are all the SL amp from the Strymon Iridium. It's been a while - but I think I put a very light amount of OCD in front of the Strymon for the lead parts to give it a little more bite.
 
Great riffage and tight as a fish's butthole. Grunty tones too. Nice balance between the guitars and punchy drums. Good call to dry it up - the number of times I've recorded a guitar and thought damn I wish I hadn't put reverb on that
 
Great riffage and tight as a fish's butthole. Grunty tones too. Nice balance between the guitars and punchy drums. Good call to dry it up - the number of times I've recorded a guitar and thought damn I wish I hadn't put reverb on that
Thanks so much for the feedback. Really appreciated. We ended up adding just a *slight* amount of ambience between the hard stops in the bridge section - the change is too small to constitute posting the latest mix. A microscopic change.
 
I shared this track about 3 years ago when I finished recording it. It's an electric gtr instrumental. I wasn't super happy with the mix at the time but just let it ride. So I've asked an acquaintance to revisit it and put a new sheen on it. I'm already making notes in my head and will listen to it on a few different playback systems as time allows over the next couple of days. It's quite a bit different than the mix that I'd done. Sonically speaking - but also... I had the lead gtr washed in some verb and delay. This version is much drier.

I welcome all constructive feedback.


Mmmm- I love the sounds you are gettting from the Strymon Iridium - I want the drums louder - that's just me - and a little nitpick - the introduction lead like riff doesn't resolve correctly (for me) - I think it needs to be more definite when you hit the end note - if you wanted to get fancy perhaps a short little whammy dive bomb - and this nothing to do with the song but I wanted vocals - the whole song just begs for vocals IMO!:LOL:
 
^^^ Don't disagree with any of that. Thank you for commenting 🙏

I might not normally consider revisiting this as it was "completed" 3 years ago - but several people have - here and elsewhere - said that it should have lyrics. I'll give that more thought.

(FWIW - my wife gave the track it's title)
 
Last edited:
Solid mix for sure - at first I thought maybe it needed vocals but it holds it's own nicely as an instrumental. Great playing, and solid tone on the lead and rhythm, which has a nice attack/chugginess to it. I listened on monitors, and my crappy little phone speakers as well, and it translates well on that - if you can sound good on my phone you're gold 😆.
 
Very nice. Guitar tone is nice. I like the way I can still hear the body of the wood.
Also like the composition and how it blends classic southern rock with newer jazzy styles. Especially during the stops.
Nice little wink at the end too.
I can hear everything on my phone so the next time I’m at my control station I’ll spin it through my JBL towers.
Good job buddy.
 
Back
Top