Sir Dingo said:
The point being, if you have no great outboard pre, and you track say, vocals via your digital console's pre-amps digitally to tape, then send that dry track to someone to run through an Avalon or Manley, etc., you will certainly benefit from a improvement in quality
Dicko,
Re-read my post.
The benefit derived from using a good mic pre lies solely in the process of actually plugging your mic in to it before you track. The reasons are many, and they have to do with impedence matching between the mic and the pre . . . gainstaging, slew rate, frequency response, transient response, and the list goes on. What makes a good-sounding mic pre sound good are the physics of the interaction between the mic and the pre
as the mic is plugged in to it.
You can't change that by sending it through a mic pre again. You
can, however, degrade the signal quite a bit by going through an extra D/A conversion, then taking the signal back down to mic level (effectively reducing it's resolution down to about less than 8 bits I imagine), then adding more noise and more distortion on it's way to yet another A/D conversion.
Think about it, Sir Dildo. You do know there's a difference between a line-level signal and a mic-level, don't you? And you do know which of those a mic pre was designed for, right? But I'm assuming you don't know what's happening to the signal when you take it back down to mic level and then back up to line level. Especially a digital signal. If you did, then you wouldn't be spewing all of this uninformed crap.
If you take something that's already been tracked through a shitty mic pre . . . running it through a good one is [size=large]
NOT[/size] going to improve the sound, and should, in fact make it worse. Possibly much worse.
If I have to explain the scientifics of all of this to you, then it's obvious that you are
not technically qualified to make a judgement call on this.
What you are saying is misleading and false.
And I apologize for being so harsh with you on this, but in truth, I am trying to help you . . . and I am trying to prevent others from making bad decisions. Kind of a tough love approach, I admit, but it is for your own good, and I mean it with the best of intentions. It's hurting me more than it's hurting you, and you'll thank me for this later.
