Kick mic problem

  • Thread starter Thread starter TamaSabian
  • Start date Start date
TamaSabian

TamaSabian

Peruvian skin beater
I´m using PRO 25 mic (not ATM 25 ) for kick recording (not EQ at this moment). When mix time comes I have to boost the 3-6 range and cut the 300-400, I´m talking about 11-15 db in both cases. I know something is wrong here, my kick do have a click sound without a mic, not to high in pitch but I can feel it. Where´s the problem, mic placement???, my room???, is the mic itself???.
Do you think a clip of my kick with and without EQ could help you to tell me what it is??.

Thanks

TS
 
I'm not quite sure I understand what you're trying to ask...apparently you're not getting a sound you want.

If you could answer these questions, I can help you out better.


First, what sound are you trying to go for with your bass drum?

Second, what other equipment are you working with?

Third, type of drums and the heads you are using?

Finally, what kind of room are you working in? (large, small, cement, jipsen board, etc).
 
Heres how i get my snappy kick Tamasabian.

1.take the front head off of the drum.
2.Stick some pillows or a blanket in there aginst the batter head to kill off the ringing.
3.loosen the head on the batter side to get more "slap" out of the head.
4.use a plastic or even better a wooden beater.
5.stick the mic in the drum level with where the beater hits the center, place it slightly off axis.
6. i dont add or subtract any lows when i eq, i add 2k all the way up to 9k regions till i hear what i'm looking for.
This works for me YMMV.

Note that im using an Audix D6 predominatly, but a md 421 or a 57 works fine too.

Also, im not sure how much snap/click you're looking for, but a company called Danmar makes these click plates to put on your batter head.
Be warned though, they are VERRRRY clicky.

If youre looking for a boomy kick leave the head on and mic it at a distance to taste.

Good luck t0 you! :)
 
It looks like my question wasn´t clear. I like to know how much EQ do you add to your kick mic when mix time comes. Do you get a click sound with no EQ or you need to add it anyway because no one can get a click out of his kick without any EQ. I need to know if there´s something wrong with boosting or cutting too much in the highs and lows just to achieve the click sound I like.

LRosario thanks for your prompt response, I´ll answer one by one

First, what sound are you trying to go for with your bass drum?
I want a click just enough to be listen through the mix, an average click if you can call it that way. I do some pop/rock/alternative kind of music.

Second, what other equipment are you working with?
To record my drums I use the 4 mic technique (snare, bd and 2 oh), the one you can find here in the forum. The mics I use are SM57, PRO25 and MXL603. I send the kick & snare through the XLR ins of my Delta 1010lt. Then I send both 603 to my Behringer UB1002 then to my Delta. No external units, like reverb, gate or compressors. All mics with no EQ.

Third, type of drums and the heads you are using?
I have a Rockstar DX japanesse drum kit. All the heads are REMO, pinstripes for toms, powerstroke III for kick, ambassador coated for snare. The kick front head is the orignal one with a hole made by my own. My kick has a foam ring inside, I tuned the batter head very loose, sometimes I have to adjust some lugs because they sound when I kick hard. As I mentioned I like the sound I have without a mic.

Finally, what kind of room are you working in? (large, small, cement, jipsen board, etc).
The room is small with cement walls, wood floor, some carpets on it, with bookshelfs and furniture inside.

Hope this information could help you to help me.

TS
 
Well your problem does not sound like an EQ issue. You need the mic placed better. I use the Pro25 a few tiems a week gigging. I use it live, but I am very familiar with the mic. Try placing the Pro25 inside the kick drum and point the mic somewhere between where the beater hits the head and the top of the head as if you drew a straight line up from the center. You might be catching too much boom due to where to mic is sitting. Experiment and move the mic around a little while you have someone listen to it and find the sweet spot. As for how much EQ to add to a kick drum is definetely not universal. It depends on a lot of factors. Tweak the EQ until you get a full rich sound.
 
GAB, I think you´re right, the placement is crucial, and I haven´t spent much time doing it and trying to find "the spot". Is good to know that there´s no universal rules about EQ and sometimes you can break them.

Thanks
 
to get a good click without too much hassle, i've found that if you find something like an old credit card and cut it up into squares and place two together and gaffer tape them to the spot where your beater hits.
 
Tama,
You don't have a metal kick thingy on the beater do you???? What click/pop are you talking about?
 
Blink 182 said:
to get a good click without too much hassle, i've found that if you find something like an old credit card and cut it up into squares and place two together and gaffer tape them to the spot where your beater hits.
All you need to do is loosen the head a bit. This trick with the gaffers tape will eventually leave you with a sticky beater. And who wants that?
 
Gab, I do sort of rock/pop/alternative kind of music. I don´t want the click sound of metal or hardcore music. I use a plastic beater. But I repeat I do get a click sound out of my BD but when I place the mic inside and hit record, the final result sounds boomy with no click, that´s why I have to boost around 6k and cut about 400hz to get a click that I want. And when I say boost & cut I mean 11-15 db in both situations.
 
Try using two mics. A bass drum mic placed half out and half in the drum, and also an sm58 or something like that placed right up almost touching the inside skin of the drum facing towards the beater. This way with good mixing (and kik drum) you can acheive the boomy kik sound and also get a real punchy sound too. Compressing and maybe gateing these will bring the kik drum right out in the mix if that is what you are looking for.
 
ecktronic said:
Try using two mics. A bass drum mic placed half out and half in the drum, and also an sm58 or something like that placed right up almost touching the inside skin of the drum facing towards the beater. This way with good mixing (and kik drum) you can acheive the boomy kik sound and also get a real punchy sound too. Compressing and maybe gateing these will bring the kik drum right out in the mix if that is what you are looking for.

Could someone tell me if this method would cause phase problems.
Because of the two mic's being "out of phase" in relation to the kick being the source. And if there were phase problems,, that would greatly reduce the "boom" of the kick....
Wouldnt it?
 
BTW, not trying to step on your toes there ektronic.
Its just a question ive wondered about for a couple of weeks.
 
It can cause phase problems, but if you play with it, you can get the phase to cancel out the 400hz range that you don't want anyway.
You can also line the tracks up in your daw so they don't cancel.
 
TamaSabian said:
It looks like my question wasn´t clear. I like to know how much EQ do you add to your kick mic when mix time comes. Do you get a click sound with no EQ or you need to add it anyway because no one can get a click out of his kick without any EQ. I need to know if there´s something wrong with boosting or cutting too much in the highs and lows just to achieve the click sound I like.

LRosario thanks for your prompt response, I´ll answer one by one


I want a click just enough to be listen through the mix, an average click if you can call it that way. I do some pop/rock/alternative kind of music.


To record my drums I use the 4 mic technique (snare, bd and 2 oh), the one you can find here in the forum. The mics I use are SM57, PRO25 and MXL603. I send the kick & snare through the XLR ins of my Delta 1010lt. Then I send both 603 to my Behringer UB1002 then to my Delta. No external units, like reverb, gate or compressors. All mics with no EQ.


I have a Rockstar DX japanesse drum kit. All the heads are REMO, pinstripes for toms, powerstroke III for kick, ambassador coated for snare. The kick front head is the orignal one with a hole made by my own. My kick has a foam ring inside, I tuned the batter head very loose, sometimes I have to adjust some lugs because they sound when I kick hard. As I mentioned I like the sound I have without a mic.


The room is small with cement walls, wood floor, some carpets on it, with bookshelfs and furniture inside.

Hope this information could help you to help me.

TS




Thanks for the info...

Ok lets see....lets do this piece by piece.

First, knowing the sound you want, you have to consider what freqs are going to act on that specific sound. I call it "visualizing the sound".

For the clip sound to be prominent, it's probably going to be on the higher portion of your low end. In a bass drum, I would say around 125-450hz.


Looking at your drum specs and heads, you should have no problem there. However, consider your drum beater. Wood tends to give a focused "slap n punch" sound while softer beaters will give your more of a muffled "thud".

Loosening your drum head makes a big difference, try it out.

So in your case, a solid/smooth surfaced beater would be up your alley.

As mentioned, mic placement is crucial. You could either a) aim your bass drum mic slightly off center of the beater side of the drum or b) have another mic just for that purpose.


Your mics should also cause no problem. However, be very cautious with the beringer. I have no problems with them, but they do tend to be a bit noisy.


Also, caution with the cement walls. You'll risk phase issues and excess reverberation. Definitly not cool when you're trying to isolate your drums.



Ultimately, consider something we refer to as "the equalness curve". What this explains is that by nature, we tend to be more receptive to mid range frequencies. So you would find yourself boosting lows and highs just to even out the sound better. Have you ever seen a typical EQ setting for a live show? If you notice, it looks alot like a V, and for that reason.


Of course remember that the higher you go in amplitude, the flatter your eq curve will get. If I remember correctly, all freqs even out at about 180db, but your head would explode before it gets that loud.

So yes, you will naturally find yourself raising your bass drum more than you might be comfortable with. That is perfectly normal. Panning other instruments helps open up more space for your bass drum as well. As long as you're not too hot (clipping), you should be set.
 
xfinsterx said:
3.loosen the head on the batter side to get more "slap" out of the head. 4.use a plastic or even better a wooden beater.


Those two steps work just about every time. Loosening the head will do wonders in your world, and you will die a happy man with a legacy of recordings with good beater slap on the kick. In fact, I'm certain that whomever gives the eulogy at your funeral after you've lived a long and fruitful life will mention something like : "He was a great man . . . kind and loving to his family and friends. And ever since he loosened that head and ditched the felt beater, he sure did get a tight kick sound."

Trust us on this one.
 
Thanks LRosario and chess, but how much loose the head should be, is there any problem if I see the wrinkles on it???. The powerstroke 3 comes with a patch that you can glue to the head, do you think it could help to get click sound???. I want to try it first I don´t like a sticky beater, that could happen if I have to take it off. BTW I use a plastic beater, is good enough for me.

Thanks again.

Tama
 
In general, don't look at the numbers when mixing or recording--use your EARS. If 12db of boost sounds good and gets the effect you want without clipping or distorting things--FINE. It's great, move on. :)

Moving the mics helps as well. Whatever it takes to achieve your sonic goals.
 
TamaSabian said:
But I repeat I do get a click sound out of my BD but when I place the mic inside and hit record, the final result sounds boomy with no click, .

If you can hear it, then you can record it.

Are you sure you're not losing the click due to phase cancellation with the snare or overhead mics? If you solo the kick track, does the click come through any better?
 
Bulls Hit said:
If you can hear it, then you can record it.

Are you sure you're not losing the click due to phase cancellation with the snare or overhead mics? If you solo the kick track, does the click come through any better?

I like the sound of the kick captured by the overheads. I think I must find the spot, I need to spend some time with mic positioning and listening through cans. The mic should be inside, close to the beater and off axis to capture the thud and click that I listen from the outside (whenever the beater hits the head). I need somebody to move the mic while I listen and play.
 
Back
Top