Is a computer with a SCSI hard drive good?

  • Thread starter Thread starter frank_1
  • Start date Start date
frank_1

frank_1

New member
IDE, SCSI; what is all this stuff? If I bought a computer with a IDE drive should I up grade to a SCSI? First I need to know what a SCSI drive is! What is the benefit of a SCSI drive, if any.

-What drive would you recommend and what gigs.

[Edited by frank_1 on 01-20-2001 at 21:40]
 
Do a search for "SCSI" on the BSS just in this forum and that should keep you reading for days.

To give a somewhat brief and simple answer to your questions:

SCSI stands for Small Computer Systems Interface and refers to more than just hard drives. It's a bus that can connect several different types of devices. SCSI hard drives are usually more expensive, a little more difficult to install into a PC without an existing SCSI controller, and faster for the most part. If you want more background info, use your favorite search engine and you'll get plenty of stuff. As for what you are asking concerning recording, IDE is historically thought of as slower than SCSI, and SCSI used to be recommended and used much more for intensive audio/video applications over IDE. Lately, faster IDE implementations (ATA66, ATA100, EIDE, UDMA, etc... for simplification purposes they can all be considered the same thing) have caught up enough where most people can't really justify the jump in price to the high end SCSI drives unless they just have the money and want the absolute fastest drive performance available. SCSI is still a better choice for a 10 drive, RAID5, hardware based array on a server or something like that, but beyond that IDE can do the job good enough and for less money. Some people still might swear that to do it right on a recording computer you have to use SCSI. Maybe they are right, but I think for most home recording it's just not worth the extra cost.

If you're IDE drive is 7200 RPM then you should be fine for recording. If you are looking to buy a new hard drive for recording, IDE is probably the way to go as in most cases it just requires setting a slave/master jumper and plugging in into the controller that's built onto the motherboard. 20 GB would probably be the minimum size drive I would buy now since the prices have come down so much. Find out where the current sweet spot is for price/GB and go from there. I have had good luck with Maxtor drives so far.
 
Thanks for the info!

Just one more; is a SCSI drive like a zip drive, I mean is it outside you computer?
 
Think of SCSI the same as IDE when it comes to questions like that. It's just another method of making a hard disc work and communicate with the computer. A hard drive is a hard drive is a hard drive. If you want to get specific, you could have an external SCSI hard drive, but you could also have an external SCSI Zip drive, Jaz drive, scanner, etc. SCSI is a means for communication between the computer and another device, be it external or internal. It's not a particular type of drive in a sense that a Zip drive is a drive that uses removable media. It's just a different technology for making things work together with the computer.

When you think of SCSI hard drives, think of them just like IDE drives. They look the same for the most part, they just have different insides that determine how they make data accessable to the computer and a slightly different connector on the back.
 
Okay I've got all that memorized. One More Question; Apple's have ATA drives, so is that bad or good. Is a IDE drive better then a ATA drive?
 
Apple (Macintosh) used to have SCSI as standard but recently changed to IDE for their home computers, as it's cheaper and doesn't make any difference unless you're running a server. ATA and IDE are the same disc type and you usually, for some odd reason, talk about IDE as the disc type and ATA as the transfer rate. For example, an IDE/ATA66 disc is an IDE disc with a maximum transfer rate of 66Mb/s. However, this transfer rate is pretty much theoretical and is not the sustained transfer rate, i.e. how much data you can shuffle for any period.

/Ola
 
As for your other question. Get IDE/ATA discs rather than SCSI. Search this forum if you want to know why... Get a small disc for your operating system and applications and a large disc for audio data. Small and large today would probably be 15GB for the small one and as much as you can afford for the large one, 40GB would last a long time. Get 7200rpm drives as they are faster than the 5400rpm ones and the difference in price isn't big. I like IBM drives but YMMV.

/O
 
Hey, look at that. This IS the right forum.

:D

(sorry Ola, had no idea. figured out the whole "computer recording" bms, never really came in here.)
 
Back
Top