You should really take a look at two other options besides Fender.
1) Schecter (the USA ones)
http://www.schecterguitars.com/prods.htm
Schecter is a Calfornia Company (Tom Anderson worked there in the eighties) that makes a model called the "PT" in a variety of configurations. The "PT" unofficially refers to Pete Townsend, who played a variety of Schecter tele's during the Kenny Jones era of the Who (79-83 or whenever). I have a early eighties PT (I'd like to think that Tom worked on it, but probably not) with coil split humbuckers that plays so nice it makes up for the UGLY Pink sparkle finish. The Humbuckers are very hot, I have to crank the volume down a fair bit whn I record clean sounds with it. Schecter still makes this dual humbucker model both in an American model and a less expensive Import version which I'm told is a pretty good quality.
I also just picked up a newer ('98 or so) Schecter USA "S" series Tele. (Like you I was looking for a Fender Tele of some sort on ebay for a few months) The "S" series is Schecter's "naturals" series. No heavy finish, just oil rubbed. I picked it up on a lark, which pissed off the wife, but I was really pleased at the beauty of the sound, even unplugged, when there's no heavy stuff on the wood. These "S" teles come with a standard two pickup setup, with fairly hot pickups that can be "cut" by a push pull tone knob. "Cutting" them basically drops the output to more resemble a traditional vintage tele twangy sound. This is a good idea for single coil flexibility, and my guitar guy says it is a pretty easy custom job to do to any guitar.
Anyway, I love this guitar, I basically haven't played anything else since I got it about five months ago.
Along that vein, check out Naked Guitars
www.nakedguitar.com
This was something I was going to investigate before I found my newest Schecter, they basically will build you a custom Ash body guitar, tele or strat style, with whatever pickups you want, for about 600 to 700 bucks. Their big thing is no varnish. They just do an oil rub finish on all of their guitars. Again, now having owned one with just wood and oil, I heartly recommend it, the sound is very pure and sweet, even unplugged.
Nothing against Fenders, but unless you're able to spend $1,800 or more for a custom shop job, you're really not getting "the best of their love" for lack of a less cheesy analogy. With some of these smaller companies, they just try harder
Hope this helped.