Not saying that there haven't been any good songs that had extra syrup on them....
...but the general view has been that if you can *obviously* hear the reverb, there's probably too much, so just back it off a few clicks.
When the reverb sorta melts away into the tracks, that's when it's best, IMO. It's still there, and it is making a difference (try muting it and un-muting it)...that's when it's doing its job without getting in the way, but again, there can be a certain song or track that just calls for that cavernous, long-tail reverb. What really makes reverb NOT work is when it's on every track in huge quantities..IMO.
If it's on one or two, but the other elements are dry or varying degrees...you get the contrast, and the tracks with reverb still stand out, and whole song sounds more articulate.
One of my favorite go-to digital reverbs is a Plate sim. I have a preset on one of my OTB verbs that I dialed in to taste, and made it available as two user presets, one with a short and the other a longer setting....the short gets used the most for my vocal tracks.
Then on my two other OTB reverb boxes I have a small Hall setting, one box is set short the other long, and I also dialed those back from the original preset to where they were similar in flavor to my Plate verb...but with a slightly different vibe. I use those mostly on guitars and occasionally some other things if called for.
These days I find myself pulling the reverb back much more than I use to in years past, and I've gotten into the whole dry/delay/reverb combination of tracks when mixing by only using one of those FX on a given track so I can get the contrast between them. Most are dry, a couple with delays and a couple with reverb...of course, each song is different.