How important is it that a sub and satellite monitors be from the same manufacturer?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jeffree
  • Start date Start date
J

jeffree

New member
I apologize for yet one more monitor-subwoofer question, but I've recently received some dealer contact that raises an obvious question that might interest other members here, too.

I'm about a week away from picking up a sub for my small M-Audio BX5 monitors, and I'm about 75% sure that I'll go with the matching M-Audio SBX sub. But my recent post on this topic brought me several PM dealer responses: one response that (fortunately) offered a price close to $100 off the best online price, and two other responses that offered competetive prices for for the KRK RP-10S sub (200 watts, 10") and the Tannoy TS-8 (200 watts, 8"). The latter two subs also look to be pretty good budget subs.

My question is simple: does anyone have a take on how important the conventional wisdom is to buy a sub from the same company that makes the satellites? Does it really make a difference that might override buying a more powerful/larger sub from a different manufacturer? In my case, should I spend some time finding and trying other monitors in the price range--like those by KRK, Tannoy, and even Samson--or would it be a waste of my time? (It's actually a bit hard to audition these unless I were actually to buy them all and try them in my little studio--a major pain unless it's really necessary.)

Thanks for any further wisdom, my distant mentors.

J.
 
Assuming that the manufacturer properly designs and builds the sub to be a perfect match for the satellites (and not just claim that they do) then it would make sense to stay with the same brand. I'm not familliar with the Maudio stuff so I can't say if that is the case or not.

If the other sub has a good crossover and much lower distortion then it might make sense to mix and match if you know how to calibrate everything properly.
 
Especially since you have to calibrate them anyhow.
 
Back
Top