Feedback Needed

First mix.

I don't read threads when commenting about mp3's because it can impart bias. I listen to the song and make comments.

Sorry if these problems were corrected--will listen to the 2nd mix.

Thanks!
 
Listening to second mix.

About the 11-11.5 sec mark when everything comes in there's a slight dropout. I dont think it's there in the original so maybe the mp3 encoded wrong. Listened to the whole thing. There's a couple of times this happens.

To the mix. Like the nice phat guitar tone. The drums are too dry. Snare is too clicky and muffled.

The bottom end is all over the place. Need to tighten it up. Maybe remove some lows from the guitars to make room for the bass and kick.

Hate the vocals. But thats a performance issue. Just dont like his singing style.

Overall the mix is good for your first attempt. It needs more space. It sounds claustrophobic which is mainly due to the dryness and and lack of definition.

Good work!
Tukkis
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top