
philboyd studge
New member
cephus said:I assumed that this was because you were going to do the whole bluegrass 5-string thing. If you just want to get a banjo sound for recording, then they have 6 string ones and any shitty one is good enough to take the 5th string tuner off and tune like a tenor (or the bottom 4 strings of a guitar).
I think it's hard as shit to play banjo. You always have to know where you're going. On a guitar, I can kind of live in the moment and not worry too much about the next chord change. On a banjo, you have to think at least a chord change or two ahead so you don't step on your dick. I quit playing for a while because I just couldn't play as fast as I wanted to, but then heard some slower folkie things and I know I can play that well. I always wanted to play east bound and down with the band and play banjo. Can't do it three piece, though.
Both 4 string (tuned in 5ths) and 5 string (open G) I find a whole lot easier to work out songs from a theory standpoint when compared to guitar.....but I've been kind of going to school on guitar lately and learning how and why I'm playing what I do. Anyway in open G you've only got 3 three chord shapes and one of those is just barring everything, so it's easy to form chords once you know your roots. Scruggs style rolls and melodic scales and riffs take some time and go against what you'd learn in guitar fingerstyle mainly due to the fifth string placement but practice will get you there. Clawhammer and frailing I've never done correctly but over time I've carved out a style that works for me so fuck it.
For me, the alternative stringed instruments like banjo, dobro, mandolin, mandocello, etc. are not only fun to play and get me more work but are very useful in coming up with new ideas and approaches in writing and recording, and I think help in my guitar playing.