Pro Sound
Jason,
You have to consider your pre amps, mics used,mic placement, acoustical area, playback reference,and lack of knowledge of your software.
Recording is not as easy as it seems. The "sound" comes with schooling and or experience, and hardware/equipment.
Sometimes the kiss method is the best way. (keep it simple stupid). If you have a good recording, do as little to it as possible.
Eq what needs it, gate the drums, a little chorus/delay on vocals, a light compression/eq on the final mix, do a stereo pan on the channels (kick,bass,vocals@64,guitar-1@ 55,guitar-2@75,back up vocal-1@54,back up vocal-2@74,Snare@80,high hat@50,pan the toms as they are played, as well as the over head mics. Play with these settings to suit your taste. If it sounds good mono it'll sound better in stereo.
Get enough stereo separation on the instruments. Remeber how you mix live. Don't try and push your input eq beyonds their means.
Hope this helps
Gidman