Well, I'm a bit of a newbie myself, but I went with a digital multitracker based studio and haven't regretted it yet. It gives you a lot more freedom in some ways. I can simply carry my multitracker to wherever I want to record, rather than having to lug my desktop PC off to this place and that. Plus, you can always mix on the PC (and should!) even if you go with a multitracker, and simply use it as a handy capture device. In that sense I always thought it was the best of both worlds: the power of PC editing and the ease of use of old cassette portastudios.
It's nice having actual, tangible faders. Maybe that's just me.