I tend to plug in to whatever I happen to have in my rack that isn't occupied at the current moment.
When I'm lucky enough to freelance, I tend to plug in to wherever I happen to find a spare XLR input.
If three open inputs happened to be within inches of one another, and two of them were labeled "Behringer" and "ART" ... I would definitely opt for whatever the third one was - don't get me wrong.

And if an API was within a reasonable distance of either of those, then I suppose it would tend to get the nod as well (and I might go out of my way for it).
But I generally wouldn't spend more than a few minutes' worth of thought on the topic. I really don't feel that any more is warranted when time is of the essense.
.