The buzz is probably still there with the levels up, it's just less noticeable.
There are tons of possible noise sources but the 2 easy ones to sort out are:
- CRT monitors / TVs / anything with cathode ray tubes: keep your cables away from these, they'll give you electromagnetic interference (EMI) every time.
- Light dimmers: Light switches are great, but light dimmers cause a huge amount of noise. If you have one of those sexy black living room lamps from Ikea with a dimmer switch anywhere in your studio then get rid of it!
A common but more difficult problem if you're using unbalanced cables is ground hum. If you have any software that can measure the frequency of a signal, try running the noise (with the faders turned down) through that software. Hum will always be close to 60 Hz.
If it is ground hum, your best option is to use balanced cables. Whereas unbalanced cables carry 2 signals ("hot" and a zero "ground" reference point), balanced cables carry 3 signals ("hot", "cold", and "ground"). Hot and cold are 180 degrees out of phase -- that is, their voltages are opposite. For example, hot might be -0.3 V and cold +0.3 V, at any given instant. A device with a balanced input then "subtracts" the voltages, using a transformer or an op amp, in order to arrive at the signal amplitude: 0.6 V.
This approach eliminates the need for a reference "ground" signal, and so eliminates ground hum.
Depending on the gear you're connecting, you may or may not be able to connect balanced cables. You'll have to check the specs of the gear you're using to see whether the ins + outs are "balanced" or "unbalanced".
Oh, and one last note -- you might be better off using Mute buttons for the short term.
I hope this helps Jesushimself! Cheers,
Johann