Hey Joe, I love your voice man, and you've got such nice technique and control. Those first vocal lines around 00:53 where you start low and then jump up a huge interval and land on that higher note are so difficult, and you make it sound easy. That's seriously impressive!
Recording-wise, there are a couple of things that jumped out at me. The intro guitar part, where it's clean with a relatively clean lead part going on is really cool, but the lead part sounds like it's too hot to me...it seems like it's clipping just a tad, especially right at the 00:27 and 00:41 marks. Are you hearing that too? It's a percussive picking technique, so it might just take some serious compression or maybe even waveform editing to tame those attacks.
The drums are nicely programmed, but man, real drums would be so nice. Are you guys planning to work with a real drummer? There are a couple of drums parts that really stood out to me - the cymbals at 00:14 - 00:15 were strange to my ears, and the drum roll fill leading into the full band coming in at 01:18 wasn't smooth - I'm guessing that's probably a difficult type of fill to get right with programmed drums, although I've never tried, so maybe I should shut the hell up
Regarding the song - I think it's a killer tune. In the chorus section, the musical change where you are singing "and all this fear and hatred will be gone" is beautiful...that's like a goosebumps section of the song for me. It just opens up and fits that vocal line incredibly well...that part was awesome. I hope this doesn't offend you, but I have an arrangement suggestion for you: in the third line of the chorus where you sing "what if we start all over again", in my head i was wanting to hear your lead vocal line go higher, actually up to where the harmonies are, in order to keep that part evolving and provide some additional interest and power there. Especially considering how powerful that very next line is with the musical change, I think it would be such a cool modification. I hope that's not too presumptuous of me...
I love the song man, and congrats on the new band!
Best,
Dave
davedewhitt's sounds on SoundCloud - Create, record and share your sounds for free