My take on Behringer, Alesis
Well I have to come down a little bit on both sides of the question. Several months ago I had a cheap old mixer and wanted to upgrade. I liked Mackie quality but price was too high, and their mixers do not have tape returns, so I would need lots of channels, lots of $$$. I looked at
the Alesis Studio 32 and decided that was the way to go, but found out about Behringer at the last minute. I looked at the specs of
the MX3282A and it was exactly what I wanted. I also looked at the 802A, tiny unit with 8 channels for a mere $119, and thought that would be a dandy little box to put in my upstairs computer room. I bought it, have been using it for months, and it has been flawless - quiet and reliable. My only complaint is that it does not have a grounded plug, which seems a little odd (those Germans must know something I don't...). After a few weeks I had decided to go with
the Behringer MX3282A for my new main mixer but found out that Guitar Center (the only place that seems to carry it) was out of stock and would be for months. So I bought the Alesis Studio 32. It has also been flawless, very quiet, mic preamps more than acceptable to my ears. My only dislike about it is that it's in-line design (16 channels + 16 returns) and general layout means you are flipping quite a few switchs when you go from recording to mixdown - the MX3282 has no tape returns but 32 inputs, so you would have less work to do. But this is just a matter of my getting used to the board which is not really a problem.
The biggest (legitimate) bitch I have heard about Behringer is problems with having to send broken / defective product to Germany to get it fixed. They are apparently still in the process of setting up a US service network. Until they do I would be cautious about buying one of their boards if it is going to be a serious income generator for you. I fit more into the catagory of "obsessed hobbiest" so that was not a big deal with me.