Holy smokes! This be one interwoven thread cenversation. Here's my contribution:
My son, the then 14 year-old classic-ly trained violist, begs for a guitar. You bet! Says I. Excellent! I call my brother, a professional! no kidding! guitarist, not to mention a luthier for 25 years, and ask for advice. At the time, I'm looking at some of these Fender acoustics, which seem to play and sound pretty good for $200. Nah, he says. Not bad, but listen! I've got a Takamine copy of
a Martin D28, who knows how much of it is plywood, but hey! I've got her set up pretty good and stuck a peizo pickup in her. Plus she's had the livin' heck played out of her, so she's nice'n ripe and I'll sell her to ya for $200. Ok, sez I.
Up until then I'm a nylon string classical-type player. I start messin' around with this Takamine - what an action! This is how I figgered playing an electric would feel. She's not real loud, but she plays real nice.
Fast forward to now, six years later. In the meantime, my son has got a cheap Telecaster and has just about thrashed it to pieces. He's gonna move out soon, so I've got to get a steel string acoustic 'cause he's takin' the Takamine, which I have been playing ALOT since we got it. So after lots of looking and playing, I get myself a cheap (relatively) DC-1 Martin. I have to wrassel it a bit more, got to get it set up sometime soon, but it is loud and sweet. The son's Tele is sent off to my brother for restoration and to be hot rodded, and now the son is playing the old Takamine through his Fender Evil Twin and making sounds I can't believe!
What am I saying? Find a guitar player you like and trust and have him or her check out used instruments to find an inexpensive used axe that somebody has loved and played and cared for - regardless of the make. Or buy an intro model Martin or Guild or whatever and get somebody ggod to set it up. I wish my new Martin played as easy as my son's old Takamine or my buddy's Yamaha... but they both hunger after my Martin...