What's Soooo Bad About It?
Because it's a silly rap/pop tune? Yes. Commercial? Very. Recorded well? Obvie. Made them millions of dollars? You bet!
It's no worse than Queen's "We Will Rock You" or "We Are the Champions."
I say a good song is one where all elements come together and mesh successfully as a whole. It could be Martina McBride, Kid Rock, Baha Men, Madonna, Dead Kennedys, the list goes on and on.....btw, ever hear of Tom Kelly & Billy Steinberg? You know what tunes they wrote? Betcha!
What's your idea of a great tune?