Are external word clocks worth it?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Muyukiguki
  • Start date Start date
It HIGHLY depends. What interface/converters are you planning on clocking to?
 
Thanks, Ethan. I've been looking for links I could post when people ask this question (over and over). It takes too long to write up an explanation every time. :D

More to the point, adding to what the article says about jitter, the stability of an audio interface's clock is more dependent on the quality of the PLL (phase locked loop) circuit in the interface than the stability of the source clock itself.

By the time you get through a four foot long word clock cable, the edges of the clock pulses are dramatically rounded and the PLL circuit is having to guess where the start of the pulse actually is. If you have a poor PLL circuit in the interface, your clock jitter will actually be worse with even the best external clock than with the internal clock.

Further, if you have a good PLL circuit that averages out the pulse timing correctly, a crappy external clock will be similarly averaged out, and will end up being just as good as the good external clock... and so will the internal clock....

In short, barring exceptionally bad internal clocks (or devices with separate input and output clocks) on a few cheap/broken-by-design devices, I have a hard time believing that there is any benefit to external clocks. External clocks are great if you have lots of devices and want to be able to keep them all in sync. Otherwise, they are not a good way to spend your money, IMHO.
 
Of course they do - how else can they get the uneducated masses to part with their money? Seriously, jitter is a total non-issue, and is the very last thing anyone needs to worry about. And even then it's a crock. More here:

Artifact Audibility Report

This is closely related:

Dither Report

--Ethan

thanks for the links !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

great site .. oh and thanks for the soundfonts :)
 
i'm with ethan for the most part... the possible exception being if you need to provide whats called "house sync" for a multi room facility... but dont worry by the time you get there you'll know it...
 
the possible exception being if you need to provide whats called "house sync" for a multi room facility

Yes, of course. But that's a far cry from the BS claims of "subtle improvements in clarity and imaging" you see from the sellers of word clocks. :D

--Ethan
 
External clocks are great if you have lots of {digital} devices and want to be able to keep them all in sync.

This is all you need to remember, IMO. I did add a key word for clarity though.
 
This is all you need to remember, IMO. I did add a key word for clarity though.

Well, you could theoretically use a word clock generator with SMPTE capabilities to keep your analog devices locked as well, but.... :)
 
thanks to the OP for bringing this up as I too found an external master clock for sale and was considering getting it, but realized that I only work with a laptop and a novation x-station (one soundcard). And thanks for everyone else for clearing the air of all the hype around jitter.
 
Back
Top