This technique ("Recorderman" modification of Glyn Johns technique) would work better (maybe only a little) with two MXLs instead of two 57s, but it's still what I'd recommend, and it's what I do, but with two condensers and two 57s.
1 - 52 in the kick, obviously. Where in the kick depends on the sound you want - close the the beater and with a pillow for a more
modern sound, more in the middle with the skins a'ringin' for a more
vintage rock'n'roll boom-boom.
2 - 57 on the snare. Put it up under the high hat pointed down as much as the drummers setup will allow pointed toward the center of the snare about an inch to an inch and half above the rim, and pointed away from the centerline of the hi-hat as much as possible. The idea is to get the hi-hats as much as you can into the dark zone of the mic so that you get lots of snare and as little hat as possible.
3 - MXL mic about 2 and half to 3 feet abovethe center of the snare, and 6" or so toward the high hat side of the kit, capsule pointed toward the center of the snare.
4 - 57 over the drummers right shoulder. Using a mic cord adjust the placement of this mic so that it is the same distance from the center of the snare as the MXL mic, and the same distance from the center of the kick drum as the MXL mic. This can be a little tricky, but it can be done. You just have to move it up and down and forward and back until you find that spot. Point this mic at the center of the snare just like the MXL.
The idea behind the placement of mics 3 and 4 is to make sure that the sounds from the snare and the kick arrive at the same time in both mics to avoid phasing issues with the kick and snare since these are generally set right in the center of the mix. Record these two as a single stereo track with the levels adjusted so that the kick and snare sound centered. Record the other two mics each to its own track. Finally, once you've tracked everything, find a snare drum 'crack' in you DAW and zoom waaaaaaaaay in on it. You'll see that it arrives in the Snare track a few msec before it gets to the Overheads. Slide the snare recording until these line up. Zoom back out and do the same thing with the kick. Find an isolated thunk, zoom in on it and line it up with it's waveform in the Overheads. There will be some misalignment of the snare signal in the kick drum mic and the kick signal in the snare mic. Don't worry about that (A. - 'cause there's absolutely nothing you can do about it, and B. - because those "bleed through" signals will be very low level compared to the primary signals on their own channels and in the overheads).
That's it... this method will give you a nice spread signal of the whole kit from the stereo overhead pair, and tight, dead centered/phased aligned kick and snare in the middle of the mix. Depending on the drummers setup, you may need to coach him to adjust his playing slightly ("Hit the toms like they owe you money. Hit the cymbals like they're your grandmother's china." is how I was taught.)
This setup or slight variations of it have been used for tons of
classic recordings (Led Zep, Beatles, Who, and many others from the 60s and 70s).
Good luck!
J