Active Member needs help: Should I go electric?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jaykeMURD
  • Start date Start date
Haha, I stumbled across my old thread here and what do you know!
I'm revamping it!

So here I am 9 months later, and no babies (elec. drumset).

Lost a job, wrecked a car, you know all that good stuff.

As far as practicing goes, I was able to play a lot for a month or two, until I was moved to a different shift, which rendered me unable to practice during the week. I like the hours I work, and I'm lucky to have the job that I do, so I won't change that. It's been a downward spiral in skill for about 2 months now.

Anywho. Back in the same predicament, except now I'm looking into the recording aspect. The practicing is turning into full-fledged recording. I've been writing and composing songs prolific-ly and tend to hit a major road block when it's 3AM on a Monday and I need to get a drumline down. It KILLS me. Often times I'll hit that roadblock and will trash the song. A hard-rock song with everything but drums is really weak and makes me sad....therefor stomping my will to finish it.

As a matter of fact, a friend of mine was browsing through my saved projects and listened to a few "trashed" projects, and was blown away.
"Dude, why haven't you finished that?"
"What happened to this song?"

After about 30 minutes of this I realized the severity of my problem.
I need to record drums SILENTLY (almost silent).
So now sound quality will come into play.
I've done a little more researching and got the chance to play on one of Hart's High-end kits. Roland TD20 brain, of course. It was pure heaven. Sounded fine to me, and I would venture to say the quality was good enough for semi-pro recordings. Of course, all was heard through some cheapo cans, but nonetheless.

The only real major concern I had with recording edrums was the "human" aspect. When you hit the snare, you never hit it exactly the same (basically), therefore you get different sounds, which is the opposite sound a trigger and brain produces. Very uniform and machine-like. Now, I didn't get to spend 3 weeks programming and tweaking the module, so for all I know the parameters can be edited to suit.... but in the long run I think the decent modules will fill my void.

I've also begun fiddling around with DFH and things of that nature....now I'm wondering if I couldn't just use my computer as the brain. DFH:S really does sound better than the td20 in my ears, but can a complete trigger drumset be plugged into my computer and recorded that way?
I'm just worried. Then again, say I drop 3-4k on one of these nice Roland kits, I have 30 days to beat the shit out of it and return it if I like.....

ohhhhhhhh. Someone let me borrow their edrum kit! :(
 
I totally recommend going the DFHS route, or any of the other VST options out there.. Addictive Drums is my favorite at the moment. I play my Yamaha DTXplorers through it and practically orgasm when I hear how real the kit sounds. The only possible drawback depending on the kit you buy is the drums may need to be remapped. Rolands probably don't have this problem as much as Yamahas, though Addictive Drums does use its own weird mapping..

You may also notice a very slight delay when playing, especially faster beats. But this depends on your soundcard. My M-Audio 2496 has about 17-18 ms latency, and I notice it when I play.. but not enough to matter too much if I concentrate.

Having said that, there's no reason you can't record that way, in fact from the sound of your situation I absolutely recommend it. Snares etc will sound a lot more realistic because there is more variation in the samples.. the velocities are detected just fine from the kit.. and it results in a much more convincing sound.
 
Back
Top