A Capella "Edelweiss"

Wabatuckian

Wabatuckian

Member
This is a song that my mom sang to me when I was a young child, and I sang to my daughter. Mom always pronounced it as "Adel-vice", so that's what's natural for me.

I feel I do OK singing this, but have trouble applying whatever I do to everything. Maybe I should warm up with it before I record.

Anyway, please tell me your thoughts. Do I sound better here? (I downsampled the MP3 so I hope there's no trouble opening it. If there is, I'll put it on YouTube.)

 
Are you posting for comments? Not to be anything - but you don't have a good singing voice - but I can't tell why you are posting - if it's to get constructive criticism - then I would say you need to work your vocals over and over - get a vocal coach so you can avoid singing mistakes and work your vocals like no tommorow- you don't sound natural so you have to put in the work - if you don't want to or don't care - then publish anything you want - but be prepared for the reactions.
 
If you have started using Reaper, it has an "autotune" VST called ReaTune. Put your vocal in Reaper, add the ReaTune plugin and watch how far off pitch your notes are. It will show things graphically. It's basically the same thing that Youtuber WingsOfPegasus does in analyzing vocals to show when artists are either pitch correcting or using prerecorded vocals in live performances.




You can record yourself doing something as simple as Do Re Mi Fa So La Ti Do and then look to see how accurate your pitch is. You'll never be perfect, but you can improve with practice. Record yourself and listen to it. You will know when you are singing well, you won't need anyone to tell you. It can be learned. Look at Jim Nabors. His speaking voice was pure Alabama drawl, but the man had an excellent baritone voice.
 
Are you posting for comments? Not to be anything - but you don't have a good singing voice - but I can't tell why you are posting - if it's to get constructive criticism - then I would say you need to work your vocals over and over - get a vocal coach so you can avoid singing mistakes and work your vocals like no tommorow- you don't sound natural so you have to put in the work - if you don't want to or don't care - then publish anything you want - but be prepared for the reactions.

I'm posting to get what I can get, to try to find what direction I should take to improve, because I flat have no idea and don't think there are any vocal coaches around here.

I want to improve but have no idea how. YOU'RE NOT GOING TO HURT MY FEELINGS, DUDE. I promise.

Listen: I make parts for an old Russian military surplus rifle for a living.

I was told it could never have a good trigger, so I invented an excellent trigger for it.

I was told it was inaccurate, so I developed a system to make it shoot up there with modern rifles.

Folks told me my mountain bike sucked, so I learned about modern bicycles and built it into one of the best ones in town.

I put myself out there and it doesn't bother me to publicly fail. It bothers me much, much more to not have the knowledge or direction to fix what I want to fix.

That's why I'm here, to find the knowledge I need, to break down the issue and examine the parts and fix them one by one.

I'll settle for being a mediocre singer if I'm better than I am now.
 
Last edited:
If you have started using Reaper, it has an "autotune" VST called ReaTune. Put your vocal in Reaper, add the ReaTune plugin and watch how far off pitch your notes are. It will show things graphically. It's basically the same thing that Youtuber WingsOfPegasus does in analyzing vocals to show when artists are either pitch correcting or using prerecorded vocals in live performances.




You can record yourself doing something as simple as Do Re Mi Fa So La Ti Do and then look to see how accurate your pitch is. You'll never be perfect, but you can improve with practice. Record yourself and listen to it. You will know when you are singing well, you won't need anyone to tell you. It can be learned. Look at Jim Nabors. His speaking voice was pure Alabama drawl, but the man had an excellent baritone voice.


Ok, so "Edelweiss" didn't sound ok? Because I really can't tell.

I totally didn't know that about Reaper, and will check it out first thing tomorrow. Thanks! ReaTune sounds like an excellent tool.
 
Ok, so "Edelweiss" didn't sound ok? Because I really can't tell.
I'll take a stab at this. It wasn't terrible, but your voice wasn't steady. You need to practice.

What I do when I'm learning a song, if it's a cover, I sing along with the original, or the version I want to copy. I do this when I driving or have spare time. Do it when no one is around so you can concentrate and not worry what someone thinks.

Practicing something you like or want to learn makes all the difference. Plus, you have a reference to judge how you are doing. Practice singing the song separately from learning to play the music parts so you can concentrate on what you are doing. I say this, because there are some songs that I cannot play and sing at the same time. The vocal is too demanding for me. I can eventually get there, but I always record the music and vocal separately anyway to get the best performance.

Just keep working at it. You may not see much improvement initially, but eventually you will. If you are looking for feed back here, practice the song for at least a couple of weeks. And post the original if it's unusual so we can hear what it should sound like. I'll admit, there are some posts I've listened to, that have no clue how it should sound because I'm not familiar with the genre or song.

Don't be discouraged, and don't give up.
 
I'll put my old music teacher's hat on. There is one BIG thing that you probably don't know. The clip goes through almost every key. Adelweise - the a, the del and the weise are quite strange intervals to sing. Let's assume that the version you want to do is in C Major - as in the all white note scale. The first note is the Major 3rd - E, the second is the 5th - G and the third is supposed to be a 9th - as in a D. What happens is you don't sing the correct third note, and then you are in a new key, so your next first note is wrong - you try to sing the second, which is a different note from last time because you changed key, and then the difficult third goes way wrong again, putting you into yet another new key. By this time your brain can't work out how you need to sing so high, so you try to drop down and miss the note again. If you play the notes on a keyboard, can you sing in tune with those? Acapella needs really good tuning. You may be able to learn it, or you might not. It sounds like you mare not 'supporting' your voice, singing in your throat, not from lower down - so notes kind of choke off, or suddenly silence. The tone of your voice suggests it's probably better than you think, but you're not working it properly.

Rick Beato is a great musician - but a good example of somebody who can sing, but isn't a singer. That's very important - but he has a great video on intervals.
 
If you have started using Reaper, it has an "autotune" VST called ReaTune. Put your vocal in Reaper, add the ReaTune plugin and watch how far off pitch your notes are. It will show things graphically. It's basically the same thing that Youtuber WingsOfPegasus does in analyzing vocals to show when artists are either pitch correcting or using prerecorded vocals in live performances.




You can record yourself doing something as simple as Do Re Mi Fa So La Ti Do and then look to see how accurate your pitch is. You'll never be perfect, but you can improve with practice. Record yourself and listen to it. You will know when you are singing well, you won't need anyone to tell you. It can be learned. Look at Jim Nabors. His speaking voice was pure Alabama drawl, but the man had an excellent baritone voice.


Ok, so "Edelweiss" didn't sound ok? Because I really can't tell.

I totally didn't know that about Reaper, and will check it out first thing tomorrow. Thanks! ReaTune sounds like an excellent tool
I'll take a stab at this. It wasn't terrible, but your voice wasn't steady. You need to practice.

What I do when I'm learning a song, if it's a cover, I sing along with the original, or the version I want to copy. I do this when I driving or have spare time. Do it when no one is around so you can concentrate and not worry what someone thinks.

Practicing something you like or want to learn makes all the difference. Plus, you have a reference to judge how you are doing. Practice singing the song separately from learning to play the music parts so you can concentrate on what you are doing. I say this, because there are some songs that I cannot play and sing at the same time. The vocal is too demanding for me. I can eventually get there, but I always record the music and vocal separately anyway to get the best performance.

Just keep working at it. You may not see much improvement initially, but eventually you will. If you are looking for feed back here, practice the song for at least a couple of weeks. And post the original if it's unusual so we can hear what it should sound like. I'll admit, there are some posts I've listened to, that have no clue how it should sound because I'm not familiar with the genre or song.

Don't be discouraged, and don't give up.

I very much appreciate this! I felt like my voice wasn't steady, but wasn't sure.

That's the weird thing about singing: in anything else in life, I can diagnose the issue and then fix it.

With singing, I have to "feel" that something is off because I can't even correctly diagnose it. I don't know if this is because of a lack of familiarity or if it's the way my brain is wired.

I very much appreciate the feedback.
 
I'll put my old music teacher's hat on. There is one BIG thing that you probably don't know. The clip goes through almost every key. Adelweise - the a, the del and the weise are quite strange intervals to sing. Let's assume that the version you want to do is in C Major - as in the all white note scale. The first note is the Major 3rd - E, the second is the 5th - G and the third is supposed to be a 9th - as in a D. What happens is you don't sing the correct third note, and then you are in a new key, so your next first note is wrong - you try to sing the second, which is a different note from last time because you changed key, and then the difficult third goes way wrong again, putting you into yet another new key. By this time your brain can't work out how you need to sing so high, so you try to drop down and miss the note again. If you play the notes on a keyboard, can you sing in tune with those? Acapella needs really good tuning. You may be able to learn it, or you might not. It sounds like you mare not 'supporting' your voice, singing in your throat, not from lower down - so notes kind of choke off, or suddenly silence. The tone of your voice suggests it's probably better than you think, but you're not working it properly.

Rick Beato is a great musician - but a good example of somebody who can sing, but isn't a singer. That's very important - but he has a great video on intervals.


I like Rick Beato's stuff and will have to watch that video.

When you say it sounds like I'm "singing in my throat", that hits something I've wondered. It does feel like the song is "caught in my throat", and almost like my lungs are the bags on bagpipes and my throat, the pipes themselves.

I have no idea if this is right, or if I'm supposed to be controlling the air from my diaphragm, or what..?

I guess, where should primary control come from?
 
Last edited:
It's like playing the saxophone - the air on the reed has to be controlled and you use your diaphragm. I think it's why some singers cannot sing sitting down.
 
It's like playing the saxophone - the air on the reed has to be controlled and you use your diaphragm. I think it's why some singers cannot sing sitting down.

Ok, so, I tried several things this afternoon, but I still have to listen to the recordings.

I was not controlling airflow with my throat, but my diaphragm. What came out was deep and hard to control, but not necessarily terrible. Did sound somewhat goofy.

What it did do was vibrate my head on certain notes. That was weird. I had my eyes open and the whole world started to vibrate.

I got in my Jeep and went through a few artists. My natural voice falls in a bit higher than David Draiman and a bit lower than Kurt Cobain.

I'm not sure how to control pitch without constricting my throat. It seems like a pretty touchy thing. I managed it but it was difficult and I didn't seem to have range.
 
Back
Top