Whats the deal?? I recorded a 5 song demo for some friends all at 96khz just to find out that after its all mixed down, I couldnt even burn it to a CD without converting it back to 44.1khz. Is that normal?
The deal is that if you record, mix and master at higher resolutions - in this case, having a higher sampling rate = more samples per second, you will have a significantly better sound when it comes time to convert it down to 16 bit / 44.1 k.
If the weak link in the recording chain is at the front end, nothing you do later will improve it. If the weak link is at the very end - the CD medium itself - there is no additive effect at work. Better sound.