I like it without reverb. You're correct that it adds to the feel of a period piece to have the recording style match.
At :38 the left side guitar's punch-in is a tiny bit sloppy, but only noticeable on headphones. You might be able to do an exponential fade at the beginning of that section of the track to offset the rushed feel.
Very good playing as usual, and the recording of nylon stringed guitars is very solid as well. They're not as easy, IMO, as steel stringed.
My only gripe is the plucking style. When I listen to guys like John Williams (the classical guitarist, not the conductor) you can't hear their fingers make contact with the strings, at least not unless the piece calls for it. The faster arpeggios on this seem the slightest bit forced. The recording sounds more like Alex Lifeson on A Farewell to Kings than what is accepted as classical. Those classic music fans are real snobs! lol
Keep in mind my feedback could be completely wrong, it's been literally years since I listened to classical guitar regularly. I had the priviledge of talking music and jamming with a fantastic classical guitarist while at college, and it has spoiled my appreciation of music since.
I knew some jazz musicians too, but they really weren't very good musicians. Classical musicians master their instruments, jazz musicians just make you think they have. The fact you can even play this bit of music puts you at another level on this forum. A lot of us thnk we can play, but in reality we're mostly just hacks.
