10 best rock drummers?

  • Thread starter Thread starter DimChandeliers
  • Start date Start date
Carter Beauford is GREAT and
he's one of my favorite contemporary
drummers too.

I don't like to rate creative people because they each bring something different to the experience and I like all of it if it's done well.

I listen for drummers who have excellent technique, who also serve the music, don't use cliche's and are always thinking...finding the voice of percussion instrument that's just right to augment a particular passage or underline a musical statement. Drummers that think musically and have something to say. Drummers that don't just use
their snare to provide a sharp cracking downbeat, but know how to coax the different voices out of their snare as a good effect for the music. I tend to like busy drummers more than the "Ringo" types, but then I am a dummer and I purchase cd's and
go to concerts to see good drumming.
I think percussively, but I do admire good melodic performances
and linear songs also. (I play some trumpet and piano too.)
I tend to not think of
or seperate musical styles when I listen to good drumming. I am a drummer/tradesman and will play for all sorts of music, many times not music that I would enjoy listening to, but I find that I can enjoy playing it and bringing something to it.
I know that the drummers that I'm listing below are not
all rock drummers, but they each have that special something that they bring to the music along with incredible technique. These are all living drummers. Check the ones out that you don't know, who knows, you might find something different that you like.

Jeff "Tain" Watts (awesome jazz drummer who records with Branford Marsalis and Kenny Garrett)

Terri Lyn Carrington (Also an awesome jazz drummer. She's
with Herbie Hancock)

Done Perry (He's been with Jethro Tull for the past 20 years and he's a drummer/craftsman with great technique and very musical)

Mamady Keita (a djembe grand master from Guinea. He is THE
MAN on the djembe)

Elvin Jones (classic jazz legend that played with Coltrane and a whole lot of other greats)

Neil Peart (has all of the qualities that I listed above. He is very musical)

Ian Paice (another rock legend wih great technique and style
"up the wazoo")

Carter Beauford ( He seems to enjoy playing wth DMB. He brings SO much to that music that I can only imagine how shallow it would be without him.)

Steve Gadd ( He can be very showy
when he wants to, but usually he is just SO RIGHT on everything he plays, and can keep it simple and elegant)

Jimmy Cobb ( He's still around and he played with Coltrane and Miles. A very classy old school hard bop drummer that KNOWS his instrument and KNOWS music)

That's just ten off the top of my head that I selected from the many that I listen to. I only listed living drummers or otherwize I'd definitely have put Buddy Rich, John Bonham, Philly Jo Jones, Gene Krupa, Art Blakey,
and many others.
 
Last edited:
Lets Rock

The rock catagory has gotten so broad these days. However here is my attmenpt:

Danny Carey - Tool
Dave Lombardo - Fantomas, Slayer
Tom Penny - Dillinger Escape Plan
Ben Koller - Converge
Lee Fisher - Allen, Commit Suicide
Brian Garbunk - Teddy Duchamp's Army, Jumbo
Keith Moon - The Who
John Bohnam - Led Zepplin
James Dewees - Coalesce

Thats it for now
 
Rimshot said:
.....Check the ones out that you don't know, who knows, you might find something different that you like.


See that's what I like about these threads. Someone always mentions someone that I hadn't heard of before.

I like your perspective Rimshot.

I was just listening to a Dave Matthews song on the radio and noticed the drummer was having his way with it big time. I don't really like the over indulgent jams that his older music is prone to but that drummer sure has a blast though. You can't go wrong with that rythm section.
 
I can't really answer the question because drums are such a mutli-faceted instrument requiring many areas to to be the best in, but I kind of lean towards some of Rimshot's qualifications. I'm sure it was a bit different when I was younger.

I am somewhat dismayed to see only one passing mention of Vinnie Colaiuta! Jim Keltner? Josh Freese!? (who, by the way, has probably played on albums with no credit in place of some of the drummers some of you have mentioned!)

For as far as supporting the song, Phil Rudd (AC/DC) is waaay up on the list.

I have a question for all of the Dave Grohl lovers: are you referring to his Nirvana stuff or some of the more recent Foo/QOTSA/Killing Joke stuff?

:)
 
You can't wrong with Jim Keltner behind the kit.
I like Kenny Arnoff alot too.
Jeff Porcaro wasn't too shabby either.

How are you guys feeling about Mick Fleetwood?

:)
 
ABSOLUTELY!!

I have to agree with theletterq and Billy Furnett, those are some great drummers. As I've said before on this BBS there are probably more great drummers around right now than there ever have been in the past. More musicians I guess. That's why it's so difficult to single out just one or two.
I was in one of my local GCs yesterday and a young kid who couldn't have been any more than 12 y/o sat down at one of the 6 piece Pearl Master sets they had set up and he blew me away. I thought I was watching and hearing Carter Beauford with a little bit of Jack deJohnette mixed in. 12 years old! There's a whole lot of talent out there!

Mick Fleetwood is an okay drummer. I've enjoyed his playing. I don't think he's going to "set the world on fire" with awesome drumming riffs, but he's good and gets the job done.
 
I hear ya Rimshot...
Mick has been around for sure, but he's just one of those players that goes to work everyday. (Fleetwood Mac is the kind of band I like for the writing and guitar... I just don't notice the drums at all really, but they're there, so he's doing his job.)

The last time I was completly blown away was when I saw The Blue Man group in Chicago. They were cool (Whatever), but the drummer in their "Houseband" was far freaking out!
He was so good it was distracting me from the guys on stage.


:)
 
Best of the best:
John Bonham
William Ward
Mitch Mitchell

Newcomers who doesn't suck:
Randy Castillo
Morgan Ågren
 
10drummers

carter beauford is the best today, hands down, although i hate the band, travis barker from blink 182 is pretty dam good.
 
Best of all times:

John Bonham
Mitch Mitchell
Billy Cobham

New breeders:

Dave Weckl
Carter Beauford
 
Kind of a weird post here...


I'm glad Strange Leaf brought up Bill Ward along with Bonham and Mitchel.
In the rock sense (and including Ringo) it made me decide to wonder out loud (here) at how insane it must have been for these guys.., I mean, imagine Mitch Mitchel playing with a guy that suddenly decided he'd do something with a guitar in a way no one else on earth before him had done!
Ringo had to hang out and work with guys that could seemingly spin gold at will.
Ward and company were perhaps refelcting the darkest of society and forging it into something as heavy as the very sins of man himself!
I'm not sure where Bonham fits in to what I'm feeling about the other guys, but it must have been pretty far out to be part of a band that could nearly (Or fully) conjure up, invoke or simply present music like it was an undiscovered element such as a new fire or a new water!

Each of these guys played and were a part of music many times larger than it seems their individual talent could possibly allow.
To understand that and to really dig it is IMO such a wonderful & welcoming invitation to discover some of the why and how that the Blues, Jazz and Classical greats (of several instruments, continents and centuries) all used in a universal timeless way to push the very same "Wow!" button in us lucky mortals.


:)
 
I feel it's my duty to inject a note of Indie Snob Oneupmanship into this thread. With that in mind my favourite drummers are:

Billy Ficca (Television)
Stanley Demeski (Feelies)
Pete DeFreitas (Echo And The Bunnymen)
Dominic Young (Ikara Colt)
Gary Ainge (Felt)
Klaus Dinger (Neu!)
Damon Krukowski (Galaxie 500)
Mark Keen (The Clientele)

:D
 
For rock n roll..how about Ainsley Dunbar{sp?}..hes been on alot of great albums..theres got to be a reason!




Don
 
finally....

Dioxide said:
Danny Carey - Tool
Charlie Benante - Anthrax
John Bonham - Zeppelin
Nick Menza - Megadeth
Akira Jimbo
.

Jimmy Chamberlin - Smashing Pumpkins


Stuart Copeland - Police
Tim Alexander - Primus
Igor Cavelera - Sepultura
Dave Lombardo - Slayer/ Grip Inc.

i was waiting to read jimmy chamberlins name there... I was suprised it wasn't on anyone else's list. Oh well... But if i could pick a drummer for my band, jimmy would be the one for sure!!
 
If it weren't for Keith Moon none of these drummers would have 'that' style so im going for him.
 
Dim, as a drummer myself, I was happy to see you include the lesser known Bill Bruford on your list. For those of us growing up in the 70s, his intricate, meter-mixing work with Yes and King Crimson was unique and inspiring, a whole new world of possibilities beyond the straighter rock drummers of the time. And Bill's jazzier work ever since then has shown true maturity and growth, something we all aspire to.

Best,

J.
 
I got to see Bill Bruford along with Patrick Moraz in the Old Chestnut Caberet in Philadelphia many years ago. I sat about five feet away and still could not quite figure out some of the things hid did. I saw him years later on the Yes Union tour where he played a stand up dome cage set. I got to meet him backstage. A super nice guy and very down to earth. I saw Buddy Rich in Atlantic City around the same time in a small venue also. He was simply amazing. I have always been a big fan of Bonham and Moon as well. I can't stop watching How The West Was Won.

The thing that always amazed me about these guys is not necessarily how great they played, but how easy they made it look while doing it. After seeing Buddy in AC, I never looked at drumming the same way again. It was very cool. For those of you too young to remember or have never seen Bohnham, Moon, Buddy or Bill Bruford (who is still alive), find an old video, and check them out. They were guys who were doing what nobody else was at the time.
Paul Garvin
 
This is why I believe every aspiring drummer should subscribe to Modern Drummer magazine. It shows them there is a whole heck of a lot out there!
 
Just thought I'd drop a name that most probably haven't heard of (or maybe they have and I've just been living in a cave) - Damon Che of Don Caballero.
 
10 best drummers.

I've been a drummer for over fourty years and not one person has mentioned
Ronnie Castillo.( Sabath), rest his soul or Alex Van Hallen in the rock rhelm. Love all guys mentioned by everyone except one, very over rated which is what Ronnie said when interviewed. And even at 60 plus isn't Ginger still in great form! And don't forget Vinnie Appice! God bless . You all Rock !
 
Back
Top