I agree that the guitarist is probably the least talented of the group but they parts he plays, even though they aren't the most technical, suit the rest of the music perfectly, and allow the other members to shine. If I was creating my dream lineup of musicians I don't think I could replace any of these guys. I didnt like their last cd, the new game, but I LOVE their latest one. I haven't stopped listening to it since it came out. I imagine it's mostly country fans where you are but you aren't to far from where mudvayne started, they are a midwest band.