This being one if my favorite songs gave me high hopes.
If this was a bar performance it would be great.
However, there are timing issues, pitch issues and the singer is trying to pull off a style that doesn't seem comfortable to him. Guitar playing is pretty good but could be better. You obviously have the chops for the song (assuming you're the guitar player)
Overall it sounds like the band is not really ready to do this song in a fluid cohesive manner.
I won't even go into mix stuff, cause I simply don't think the song is ready to be recorded.
You guys have the potential to pull it off, it just needs a bit more work.
Sorry to be harsh, thats just my take.
Years ago (20), my band did a live in studio cover of Free's All Right Now.
It was a blast! Had a great time. Other people loved it..........
However, it was sloppy, not right, and I cringe at all the issues. 20 years later, both myself and the singer want to redo the song properly.
Some songs are just like that. Do them right or not at all.
The Cowboy Song is one of them.