OK I am listening to mixes tonight, stay tuned for comments . . .
zed32: damn, not bad. give it a bit more air though, and strive for a little more punch on the lows
xfinsterx: not used to judging your stuff! evil sound on the guitars, nice on the bass, excellent headphone mix too. Totally solid all around. I want the toms in the section in the middle to be huger, but that is really just a personal preference. Really this is the reference mix.
NL5: kind bright the high mids on the guitars, harsh. The vocals sound good but they need a little more room carved out for them. Good classic sound on the middle section.
Is it just me, or does this track need a wailing guitar solo
zed32 #2: I think #1 is a better starting point. #2 sounds phasey, distorted, and thin.
DonF: I think I hear where you are going with this, but you're still a ways away. Go back to the drum submix and get the snare and overheads to sound like they are in the same space as the hats and kick. The vocal verbs are to the point of distraction.
bigwillz24: you can't bury the vocals that deep. It ain't just level, it's dynamics. Your vocals still have lots of dynamics, the rest of the track has very little. The guitars are very hot in the high mids/highs where the vocals should be on top.
mrhotapples #2: hmm, kinda sorry I missed the snare reverb version, I like Def Leppard. On this version, I think the vocals are like 80% wet. Did Timmy fall down the well again?
StudioMxPx: vocals would be nice, also the snare is waaaaay too hot. Also while I liked the tom mics, I don't really want to hear the sympathetic resonance of the tom heads, instead of say, reverb.
Llarion: A bit crispy on the highs. After the intro, I think you need to back off a bit on the flanger. Really this is all over the place, some bits are quite good, other times it's very harsh. I think you should make a decision on what the basic sound should be.
jerberson12: need to watch that second guitarist's parts, they can overwhelm the track when they enter, and that will throw your levels all over the place.
OK keep 'em coming. I promise to be nicer in judging, right now I just want y'all to get these as good as you can!