What the (*&$&
What was that, he couldn't what...Use his SSL and the only other board available was a Behringer. This must be a joke, right? I mean, how the *&^% could someone int hat position be only able to find a Behringer. That story, my friend, needs some explanation or it will be taken with a HUGE grain of salt.
As for Behringer mixers, I am willing to bet that they can do a world of good for someone on a budget if used properly within their limits. A Mackie cannot sound like an SSL and so forth and so on. It is purely a question of expectaions. If you are on a budget, then exactly how is a Berhinger so much worse than any other budget mixer? Certainly, there may be some difference but anyone expecting a Behringer to be an SSl or even a Soundcraft for that matter is missing the point. If you were a race car driver, would you consider racing a Huyndai against a Ferrari? I don't thing so. Does that make the Huyndai the worst car ever made. Probably not but even so, I'll bet it beats walking.
So, to state it plain and simple, IT ALL DEPENDS. What is your criteria, what is your measuring stick, what is your problem...