When Is It Time To Sell? (Guitars and amps. Some PA Gear, too.

  • Thread starter Thread starter stevieb
  • Start date Start date
S

stevieb

Just another guy, really.
(This could turn into a long post, but I have tried to construct it like a newspaper article, with the most important info at the top, least import at the bottom- so feel free to stop reading whenever you want, and then (hopefully) post up your best, most honest opinion.?

When is it time to sell? I have several guitars and amps, most were pretty sweet deals (I am left handed, and often find southpaw guitars at great prices.) Of course, I can't play more than one at a time:), but beyond that, I am thinking maybe it's time to scale down. What criteria do you use to decide when, and what, to sell? Is yours a careful, formula-driven calculation, do you go with your heart, or somewhere in-between?

Is now, economically, a good time to sell gear? Oh, sure, the recession is cracking, very slowly, but it's been on for so long that prices for most everything are depressed, still. OTOH, maybe the money could be better "parked" elsewhere?

This question could, if you wanted it to, include all kinds of philosophical questions like "How many is too many?" and such- feel free to go there, if you want.

Personally, I have a feeling, somewhat vague, that I have too much gear. Certainly, I am not getting much use out of all of it- some guitars go months without being pulled down from the wall, and there is considerable overlap from one guitar to the next- although no two are real close to each other. IF I had two Les Pauls, for instance, I could decide which I prefer and sell the other- maybe swap out some parts before unloading #2. In fact, here are my guitars (lefty ones only- any right-handed guitars, with one or two exceptions, are only in my possession on speculation.) If you see any you think are dead wood, sing out- but please try to keep preferences or prejudices for one brand or another out of your thinking, as much as possible. I like them all, and each was, at one time or another, my favorite, if only for a little while. BTW, this is NOT any sort of me wanting to trot out what I got- some of this stuff has modest, at best, collector value. In order of aquisition:
(See abreviation guide, below.)

GUITARS

1968 Telestar Hollowbody 2pu Model. Gift from my folks when I was 11 or 12. Not a great player, but lots of sentimental value for me. One of the two right-handed guitars that is not here on spec.
60'S Kawai Bass Loose Fender Jazz bass copy, with massive all-metal pick guard and pu covers. My dad had a friend of a friend paint it purple and blue metal flake, in the 70's. the other righty not here on spec. Never gets played- I play the lefty basses, no bassest ever comes over to my house, and I rarely if ever bring it out. But what an EYE POPPER- I mean, come on, purple/blue metalflake and chrome?:drunk:
Arbor 12-string acoustic Rarely leaves it's case, but this 12 has more over- and under-tones than any other 12 I've ever heard, and a high, ringing tone. I love just listening to this one.
Seagull S6 Dreadnaught My #1 acoustic for quite a while, became my beater when I got the Martin (see below,) but sees very little play.
Westone Thunder 1A HH SB Pawn shop find, got it for a great price b/c it was sitting for-freakin-ever in the shop, unsold. I knew nothing about either the brand or the model, bought it pretty much blind, and was rewarded for my risk by getting a darn impressive guitar. Active circuitry, coil tap and splitter switches. Basically a factory hot-rod Les Paul Copy- but not in appearance- this one is so plain and simple it makes a LP Studio look like it's dressed to the nine's.
Westone Spectrum SX HSS, tap and split via push-pull pots. Locking nut and Schaller-type (don't recall make) locking tremolo- a shreader guitar. Thing is, I don't shread. But it's ALL hi-gloss red (well, hardware is black or chrome)- even the fretboard is red, and it's BEAUTIFUL.
Martin D16GTE Early model, with lots of extra trim that has nothing to do with the playing or tone, but looks great. Understated- fret markers are 4-point snowflakes, only abalone is a narrow ring at the rosette. Perhaps my best guitar, I'd only sell it because it will bring more money than any other guitar (except USA strat, see below.) Bought new, so I have the factory lifetime warranty.
Squier Standard Strat This one would be easy to let go of, if I ever get off my butt and change it back to the original pups- nobody wants to pay me what it plus the Tex-Specs in it are worth, together.
Harmony Tenor acoustic- flat top. Foundling. Fact that a different tuning makes it sound so much better limits how much I play this one, but I am slowly learning. Technically not a lefty, but completely symmetrical build (except for nut) makes it as lefty as it needs to be.
Epiphone Les Paul Standard I installed top-line Gibson pups in it, and it has a wonderful tone. My sweetest-sounding electric.
Fender USA Strat Tex-Specs in this one too. Perhaps tied with Martin for monetary value.
MIM Fender Jazz Bass I was a bass player, while in high school and early college, and as I play lefty, I CAN play a righty bass upside down, but it's not much fun having to stay alert ALL the time.
Peavey Millineum Bass Bought to convert to fretless, but I can't seem to screw up the nerve... one day, one day. Real flamed maple top makes it prettier than the Fender, but the Fender is worth more.
Greg Bennet Les Paul copy. Not an exact copy, different enough to not be boring. I removed the buckers and installed a pair of soapbars, so it would be different. but maybe it's not different enough.
Harmony Tenor Banjo Yeah, yeah, not a guitar, but close. Bought as a companion to the Harmony tenor guitar, figured I'd mess around with it for a few months then flip it. Thing it, it sorta charmed me, and helped me gain something of a rep as a multi-instrumentalist. Being called that tickles me no end.

So, what say you?

I'll cover the amps and PA gear in another post, or here, later.


Abbreviation guide:
HH- humbucker/humbucker
SSS 3 single coils, ala stratocaster
HSS- you can figure this out from the first two abreviations.
HB- hollowbody
SB- solid body
 
Never sell a guitar. I've sold three in my life and always regreted it (a Gretch Chet Atkins Country Gentlemen, a Guild 12 string and a white Strat). I have to sit down for a while now...............
 
I've only sold 1 guitar and 1 bass in my 6 years of collecting. Both within the last month actually.
Both the only ones I bought used (to help out friends) and didnt play. Now, any of the others I cant sell. I'm just... :( it's scary to think about. I guess it's a sentimental thing mostly. They're the only things I've actually worked to buy myself and each have their own special place (even if its in the closet :p)

btw, arbors are really awesome
 
but to kind of help you out, when I decided to sell to downsize just a little, I instantly went to the ones I never touched and didnt feel attached to
 
i'm with trackrat....don't sell anything. i've got every damn thing i had since i started playing 11 years ago and i sure as shit aren't getting rid of any of it, pedals included
 
I don't have a problem selling something if it's going to lead to me getting something even better and more desirable in return.

Back in the spring, I sold a bunch of gear that was no longer on my A or B list...and in return got a really nice high-end guitar amp and a really sweet preamp I've lusted after for awhile.

It's not east to part with something, and we sometimes get stupid-nostalgic and cling our first this or that (even if it's a piece of shit :D)...but you gotta' have some plan with gear rather than just buy stuff like a pack rat and then cling to everything even if you hardly ever use it.

In the last 10 years I've done a few purges of lesser quality and lesser-used gear, and step by step have replaced stuff with better gear...that includes drum gear, guitars and amps, pedals, preamps, processors and FX boxes, tape decks...etc.

AFA the best time to sell...I watch those trends on eBay. Best times to sell on eBay IMO....from March to May and from October to mid-November (forget the X-Mas period). Best time to buy on eBay...X-Mas through February and the summer through September.
 
I got too much gear too.I've often thought of selling a few things off but i still havn't.I have 4 Ibanez Pro Line V's.
The main one i've played since i was 18 (i'm 41)
The one that was stolen,found,but never gets played anymore...but it was my back up when i was in a band and it did get played a bit.Just finding it after it was stolen and getting it back makes me want to hang onto it.
The one i bought on ebay as back up when the other one was stolen.This one is pretty well beat up but it's a good parts guitar and being these V's were made in the mid eighties,parts are hard to come by.
And then there's the black one.I always wanted a black one and it plays well.

I got a Ibanez Roadster2 also that i like for mellow tunes but it records horribly for heavier tunes even at low gain levels.I've had this guitar for 20 years and don't want to part with it either.

I've got outdated PA gear that's just taking up space but i hang onto it just in case i ever decide to get back into a band.I guess if i was to sell anything i'd start with the PA gear and work from there.I'm not attached to any of it personally like i am with the guitars.

I miss about every amp i ever had but i can always find one of those on ebay.
 
I've got way too much stuff but selling it is such a PIA.
I don't want to ship amps so they're local pickup only and then I have to put up with people coming to my house.
I'm gonaa sell a few things but ONLY things I can get a good price for.
If something is worth less that 4 or 5 hundred bucks then it's not enough money to be worth it and I may as well have the damned thing for some use of my own.
 
The hardest thing about shipping amps is finding large/sturdy boxes...but I've shipped about a dozen heads, amps and 112/212 cabs in the last 5-6 years, and received as many...and never had any real issues.
I find that using FedEx Express (not FedEx Ground) and insuring for the full amount has been the most safest/fastest way to go. It costs a bit more, but hey, add it to price.

I'm not keen on having anyone come to my house to pick up stuff....but yes, getting things boxed up and shipped out is PITA. This past November when I sold a large bunch of gear (including amps and a few other large pieces), I decided to pack everything BEFORE I ever put up any listings, which ended up being the smart way to go.
I set aside one afternoon and just packed and packed, and then marked, measured and weighed every box and then stacked them all in one corner. As one sold...I just grabbed it and shipped it out. :)
 
I've sold more guitars than I would ever need to keep. Ship em out...
 
{Quote}When Is It Time To Sell? (Guitars and amps. Some PA Gear, too.{Quote}
For me the time to sell is when a pc of gear no longer fits my needs.No one rig or guitar can satisfy all of my needs so I have a lot of guitars and amps.
If you can sell something at a profit and get closer to something that fits your needs, it's a good time to sell.If you have a lot of lowend stuff that never gets any use, and the profits of selling that stuff will get you one thing you will use,it's time to sell.
 
I don't think you should have numerical limits but you should try to avoid most emotional attachment (one or two is okay, but anything more than that clouds judgment). I came to the conclusion a while back that anything I own I will sell some day, and there's nothing wrong with that. My process generally goes something like this: I start to fall out of love with the piece of gear, it goes back into storage, I pull it out later and try it, if I like it less than last time, then it moves closer to the "sell" pile, generally before I sell and I'm writing the description it gets one more chance for me to fall back in love with it. If not, I either trade it, sell it local, or if no one will give me even close to what it's worth, off to flea bay it goes.
 
I try to buy gear according to sounds I'm looking for. I mostly buy online, after trying out guitars from friends, or at Guitar Center. If the tone is what I was looking for, it's a keeper. If not, I'll hang on to it for about 6 months, to give myself a chance to find a good tone with it. If I can't, I'll usually try to offload it. Haven't had the need to sell an axe since I've gotten back into guitars, now I've got four of 'em, and about half a dozen more I'm looking to pick up. So really, keeping a guitar depends on how unique a tone I can get out of it.
 
When is it time to sell? I have several guitars and amps, most were pretty sweet deals (I am left handed, and often find southpaw guitars at great prices.) Of course, I can't play more than one at a time:), but beyond that, I am thinking maybe it's time to scale down. What criteria do you use to decide when, and what, to sell? Is yours a careful, formula-driven calculation, do you go with your heart, or somewhere in-between?

When I'm not playing them anymore.

I've sold a number of guitars over the years, some pretty common, others less so.
The reasons have all been slightly different, but that's essentially what it boils down to.

I'm kind of an Ibanez guy, but in the past I've sold or traded a (roughly in order) a RG470, RG520QS, RG2027x, RG7620, RG7CST, Schecter C7 Hellraiser, and a RG1527. The 470 was my first Ibanez, was fun, but was never serious. The 520's neck I didn't really get on with, and I traded it for my first 7, a 7620. I added a 2027 to that, a mahogany-bodied, piezo-equipped guitar and total eye candy, but I realized I didn't get on with the tone as much and kept coming back to the 7620 so I sold it (boxing it up was tough, but that's the closest I've come to regret). I added a UV7PWH to the herd, then after long deliberation sold my 7620 because it was too nice a guitar to be gathering dust. When the (exceedingly rare, perhaps one of 18) CST came up for sale, I grabbed it, played it for a while, but eventually just kept coming back to my UV because the thing was so bloody expensive I was scared to hurt it. So, I sold it - I wasn't playing it, I didn't care about the collectability, so it was wasted on me. I grabbed the C7 Hellraiser (black cherry quilt, gorgeous) soon after as a seven string "rhythm" guitar, with it's fixed bridge and longer scale, but the EMGs and I never really got along, so I sold that, grabbed a Blackjack for a bit less, and then eventually bought and sold the 1527 because it had a great neck but couldn't compare to the UV in tone so, shock and awe, I wasn't playing it.

These days I also consider keeping guitars if they don't get played much but get occasional use for a specific purpose - my UV and my Strat get almost all the playtime, but I still have the C7 Blackjack to track rhythm guitar, I have a PRS SE for the H-H six string thing, and I have a 7321 I took as partial trade for the 1527 that I meant to use for a project but is just collecting dust, so I'll probably just give it to a buddy around here or something. I also have anopther 7620, but the story there's a bit different - a guitarist friend is going through a divorce and needed cash so he had to sell it, so I offered to buy it off him, hold it until he was situated again, and then sell it back. Otherwise, that might be marked to get pared down as well, it plays great but again can't compare to the UV tonally.

I figure, they're meant to be played, and if you're not playing them it's time to sell.
 
I would sell the ones that no longer serve a purpose, but that's just me.
 
Back
Top