I'm slowly (and I mean glacially slowly) building a studio kit, and I think I need to replace my crappy hats next. My question is -- is buying used hi hats a little like buying used guitar strings?
The cheap ones I have now have a crack that I didn't notice when I bought them (used), and I haven't exactly beat them to death. Should I consider hi hats to be perishable items, or does this mainly apply to low end and/or poorly maintained sets?
(yes, I'm a total drum newb)
I have the same 1950's hihats that I bought in 1972, and another 60's AZ set and a pair of Wuhans.
Largely, cracking cymbals is due to bad technique - pounding the sound into the cymbal instead of drawing it out, although there are flaws in cymbals. Also, people are idiots when they don't use cymbal sleeves - don't buy them, go to Ace hardware and get a few feet of the plastic tubing. And check the edges of cymbals and sand out nicks before they crack.
I always buy used cymbals because, for one thing, they don't sound right to me until several decades after they are made and the metal ages.
Lots of cymbals get cracks and they should be drilled at the end and the sides of the cracks removed with a Dremel. I did some cracks in mine 35 years ago, and that saved them. It did not affect the tone of the cymbals as far as I can tell. But it's like a cavity in your tooth - fix it soon and you save it, wait and you might not be able to.
I'd buy off of Craigslist so you can see and hear them before you buy... I avoid new ones. I actually like ones with cracks for 2 reasons: I can buy them dirt cheap because "they're broken" and because it often means that someone played it a lot and for whatever reason most of the best cymbals I've used have cracks.
It's the new, shiny ones I avoid like the plague.