You obviously seem to know your stuff on this issue.
But, I'm confused. Also, I'm not a pro recording engineer.
By 'other, non US428 pci devices' I was referring to something like
the MAudio Delta 1010, the Digi001, or other similar thing. I've seen a nice Roland 24bit/24track package hardware/software, but I forget the name. I just 'assume' (here I go again!), that any of these PCI type devices would likely outperform the US428, or other USB audio devices, but then again, that's an assumption.
I think Tascam has been great about bringing great recording technology to the masses, i.e., home recording. The US428 is not one of my favorite devices, though. I'm sure people in the field may like it, and may have no problems with it, but I did. I may be an isolated case, I don't know what the stats on US428 owners says, but I didn't like it, and would not recommend it. I'm not saying I have all the answers, not at all the case. I'm just me. I don't think it's the case "that just because I'm analog, I wouldn't like it anyway 'cause it's digital" (paraphrasing). I tried very sincerely to work with the US428, and I tried hard to like it, but I could not resolve a number of technical issues, probably due as much to my computer as to
the US428. I'm sure every case is different.
Now, technically, don't you think that any of the current digital consumer audio recording (for DAW) products, such as the ones mentioned above, have good, high quality A/D-D/A's? I thought they probably did. If not, what exactly what would you recommend, when referring to "quality A/D's". Is there some brand of standalone unit for this? Without getting too tech-or-spec-heavy, what is the basic setup that you use, or would recommend someone uses.
Do you use a DAW based setup in your studio, or do you have a digital recorder such as the standalone Mackie 24 or
the Tascam MX2424? Just curious.