the Karma chronicles...

  • Thread starter Thread starter kidvybes
  • Start date Start date
kidvybes

kidvybes

New member
...the moderator here has decided the issues over the new Karma Audio microphones wasn't suitable, but the Gearslutz crew decided to put the threads back up, so for those of you interested in how things are playing out, look here:
http://gearslutz.com/board/showthread.php3?p=611372#post611372
or here:
http://gearslutz.com/board/showthread.php3?t=59987

...more importantly, one of the members here, ljmaxx just received his Karma K55 tube mic, so we can look forward to some real "hands on" input as to the mic's performance (and hopefully some sound files as well)...after all, we are most interested in the product's performance, not the sordid politics of business...
 
Last edited:
Yes, "we" are all interested in a company who is deceiving the public, got canned for deceiving the dealers they were responsible to SERVE, and are running around trying to start a new OEM re-badge mic line based on someone else's reputation.

Someone else being sE Electronics, who happen to be the someone else who let these guys GO. Goodbye, see ya. Gone.

Now "Karma" is going to serve up some justice I guess, and you're having a blast telling everybody how they MUST buy it based on the product and not the politics ie "these guys have been proven to lie and deceive and on a good day only distort the truth, but if they got a cheap mic I'm gonna get me one" while they tell you all the while they "are" sE.

But when they're called on it, oops we meant to say were...associated with them at one time.

How about the "were" part they're leaving out? www.stonerecording.com, a false retail site setup by these guys to bypass the dealers they were supposed to support? A lie? Wonder why they're "were" and not "are" in their relationship with sE currently? sE just likes firing GREAT people at random?

Dude I seriously don't get your Karma thing man but whatever, have fun.

War :rolleyes:
 
Just to reiterate:
Karma said:
"Hello I was invited to come in here and clear some stuff up on KARMA
MICROPHONES.

We are made in the factory in china that Sound On Sound wrote about and
gave its review on. Meaning we are made in the same factory that
produces sE Electronics.

Actually our business partner owns the factory. So in essence I guess
you could say that we build the mics for sE.

Yes we offer a seven day trial and a lifetime warranty. The warranty is
from the factory itself.

The microphones are not copies of any sE microphone directly, but what
we did on some of the models was make them better. Modifying them adding
better quality parts so on and so forth. Also all the mics when ordered
come with a print out from the factory of its chart it own little finger
print.

Why did we decide to come up with our own brand. Well that is a long
answer a very long one. Infact the name of the company was created you
can say from that answer. If you contact us i will be glad to talk shop
with you.

We also decided when we created this company to go back to the original
idea we had when sE was created in which they have parted from which is
giving you the best microphone for the best price. As you dealers know
if you where a dealer before 2004 and 2005 you know that they have
raised there prices a huge amount. What we are doing is going from the
prices that we feel you will be happy with. So that you, and your
customers will be happy with the price the performance and the
product-line all together.

Any questions please feel free and email us sales@karmamics.com or
respond on here.

If any of you are from a magazine and want to come and visit our factory
as Sound On Sound did then feel free and contact us we will arrange the
date for you to come visit.

Take care all."

~Karma Audio Productions, Inc.

SE said:
Hi all,

My name is James Young, and I'm one of the owners of sE Electronics International and the Shanghai facility which makes our products.

One of the Gearslutz regulars was kind enough to alert me to this thread, and another on the Gearlslutz forum involving a new brand called Karma Audio.

I'm posting just to set the record straight, and will be very happy to personally answer any questions this post raises. I'll aso be posting on Gearslutz later today on the same subject. Jules temporarily shut down the thread when I first alerted him to what was being said, because what was being said was highly inflammatory, and untrue, but we both thought it better to get it up and running again as soon as I'd had chance to construct a proper response...

We are contacting the people at Karma Audio privately to pursue some of the incredible claims they have been making on Gearslutz forum, and we are now looking for other incidences of such claims on other forums. In the meantime I have been speaking with Jules of Gearslutz about setting the record straight, since many of the claims being made are quite simply untrue.

As you all know, sE is not a huge company, but we are growing fast and making a lot of good noise in the market because of our products, and the man behind them, Siwei Zou. We've spent a huge amount blood, sweat, tears and personal money over the last 4 years really establishing the line as a bigger player, and have brought some real innovations, including products like the Gemini, the Titan and the new Reflexion Filter? i.e. we are not an OEM or copy company.

sE Electronics and the facility we run in Shanghai do not make products for anyone else. There is no link with Karma Audio and sE, other than Waylon, who names himself as co-owner of Karma on the Karma Audio web site. He used to be involved in distributing sE in the USA when it was an OEM brand.

Neither Karma Audio, nor any of their representatives have ownership of sE in any way. Their products are categorically not made in the same facility. Neither is their facility the same one that SOS visited. I refer to comments made by Karma101 in this thread:

"We are made in the factory in china that sound on sound wrote about and gave its review on. Meaning we are made in the same factory that produces sE Electronics.
Actually our business partner owns the factory. So in essence I guess you could say that we build the mics for sE."

This is untrue.

We are inviting representatives from Karma Audio to review their comments, and retract any false statements of origin and marketing. I hope they see fit to do this on this public forum.

What Karma101 has done is weave a number of completely false statements, with some elements of truth, in order it would appear, to capitalise on the success of Siwei's products.

So, again to set the record straight, here is the actual history of sE's relationship with OEM manufacturing:



Siwei Zou started his career as a classical musician with the Shanghai Opera. He has, in his time, been conductor of the Shanghai Philharmonic Orchestra, a highly successful Classical Composer, visiting scholar at the University of California, and is currently a professor of the Shanghai Conservatory. In short, a true 'golden ears'. In his role as one of the top Classical Musicians in China, he was often sent microphones by the likes of Feilo, to test and evaluate, and this led (in a very roundabout way) to his eventual involvement with Feilo. Siwei was an advisor, helping Feilo to improve the quality of their many OEM lines. In turn, he had an arrangement for them to manufacture his own, sE, designs.

This relationship ended a few years ago now when, for various reasons, Siwei decided to start his own manufacturing facility in Shanghai, called Heavenly Sound. Heavenly Sound is owned by sE Electronics. Siwei Zou and his family, myself and two other UK partners own sE Electronics International. No-one else is involved in any way in ownership of the company.

In the first year of manufacturing our new sE product line, Siwei continued two old relationships with Thomann (T-Bone mics), and Cascade, both to allow for a smoother transition for those brands in finding new production partners (as they are old friends of Siwei's), and to allow for a growth period of our own brand so the facility was able to support itself as we grew business. Those relationships are the only ones, and neither company has had product manufactured at Heavenly Sound for some time now.

Today, as was always our dream, we have the only western owned mic facility in China. We do not make products for other companies. We do not re-badge products for the sE line made elsewhere. We only make our own products and we are very proud of what we've achieved in a ridiculously short time.

We have taken not only SOS to the factory, but also two German Magazines, the French KR magazine, Audio Media, Resolution and Music Tech Magazine, as well as several large European dealers. We've done this in order to help spread the story of what we are doing, and to genuinely be open about what we are doing, why and how.

Everything about what we have achieved is based on hard work, innovation and a lot, a LOT of personal belief in what we are doing. Our workers are employed on long term, and in some cases life-long contracts, something unheard of in OEM facilities. They are paid very well, have transport laid on to and from work, free lunches etc. We even run a further education program for those manual workers who don't have a proper education. In other words, we are investing in people, not using them.

Our products are all made in-house, even flight cases are made by us and not sub-contracted. We will shortly be putting a virtual factory tour on the sE web site so you can all see the entire manufacturing process from start (raw materials like brass rods for chassis) all the way to capsule assembly and completed products. All our machinery is brand new, all electronics are assembled in clean rooms, as are the capsules (again unheard of in microphone OEM) We have recently even invested in building a full anechoic testing chamber at our facility. Again, we are not about making as much money as possible and running after two years. We really believe in what we are doing, and we are re-investing every cent we make into the facility, and making better and better products.

I am very happy to personally answer any questions my posting may throw up (I'm sure there will be questions!!), either on the Forum itself, or at my personal email address, which is james AT seelectronics.com


Thanks to you all for reading this post,

James



www.seelectronics.com

T: +44 (0) 1582 470 260
C: +44 (0) 7967 60 11 74

Karma said:
Retraction, Apology, and Truth
Hello everyone my name is Waylon Ford; I am a partner in Karma Audio Productions Inc. I used to be a partner of Se Electronics USA till we were caught in a web of politics, lies and deceit. We were underhandedly forced out of our company and were never compensated as agreed upon.

So when we were approached by Wang Qin Tai who was the partner of Heavenly Sound to start up a new company with his factory, needless to say we were game. I had been working on new designs during this time away from sE Electronics and was more than happy to partner up with a professional partner and create great products again.

At the moment I thought that what he was saying was that he and Siwei had a disagreement and wanted to start up another line of product in his factory that he had built. So I asumed that this factory was the factory he built in his partnership with Siwei. That was all on me, and was my mis-understanding and is where I was wrong in what I stated before. What he was indeed saying was that he (Mr. Wang) and his entire crew which were the technical team and brain of all the creations that have brought sE to the new era had split and were opening up a new factory and wanted to join up with us a full partners in this new venture and factory.

So
basically I am here to state that I made a mistake in saying that we are the factory that makes sE Electronics microphones and I am being man enough to say I apologize and retract my statements. What I now know I should have said is that we are the team of people that made sE Electronics who they are now we are the group of people in the US and in China that designed the new microphones and named them and in essence gave birth to them. We took a company then known as Silicon Entourage Electronics in the year 2000 and in 2001 brought to life SE Electronics and in 2003 created the sound performance and visualization of SE you see and know of today. It was our hard work and desires that brought it, a no name company Silicon Entourage to a proud well-made product, company and factory now called SE Electronics.

I hope you all except and understand my mis-understanding of what was said to me. Dan Richards has KARMA on his workbench and will give you a review of our mics and we will take it from there. I know what we are capable of and so should you. After all you all have seen what this group of people can make in the past just imagine what we can do in the future.

PS. James I have never heard from you call me if you wanna talk here is my number.

Waylon Ford
Karma Audio Productions, Inc.
1.408.446.2928
http://www.karmamics.com

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A little history lesson in the matters of sE Electronics, USA and sE Electronics.

In 2004 after four years hard work to re-build and re-brand the sE Electronic brand microphone and tons of money spent on the marketing. James Young in the UK and Siwei Zou formed a company called sE Electronics International.

They used a very low and dirty way to get rid of sE Electronics USA. The sE Factory was created by to partners. Siwei Zou and Wang Qin Tai. Mr. Wang is the person who was responsible for the new technology and designs that have in conjunction with se electronics USA moved sE to the next level of performance. Mr. Wang is the partner that has the extensive technical knowledge and has all the best technicians in Shanghi. In March of 2005 due to a personal conflict of a business matter Mr. Wang separated himself and his team of technicians from Siwei Zou and the sE Electronics Company.

Mr. Wang then merged with what used to be sE Electronics USA to form a microphone company and factory that would ?A? stay on the track of producing new and better quality microphone designs and ?B? supply them at the price that every-one could afford. Which was the original goal of sE Electronics, but as we all know they kept raising the prices to the dealers, which caused them to have to sell them at a higher price to the customers. So hear we are a westerned owned mic company and factory in shanghai, china and we are called KARMA AUDIO PRODUCTIONS INC. There is a reason why they chose to call the company KARMA. Karma has since contacted the old sE Dealers, and they have all shown much support to the newly established company.

We have had mic shoot outs with many brands not just sE and Karma very often the one on the top, not only in sound and performance, but in all scenarios the cases, the shock mounts, the bodies, and the power supplies are all very superior to all other brands. Every karma mic comes with a lifetime warranty and the actually printed response chart which sE would never supply.
 
Sorry, but the "Karma" mics are just damn ugly and I don't trust any mic that has that kind of slotted grill. It just screams "reflections" and "high end smearing".

No thanks. I'll pass.
 
PhilGood said:
I don't trust any mic that has that kind of slotted grill. It just screams "reflections" and "high end smearing".

...interesting point Phil...the grill design seems to be derivative of the current stream of ribbon microphone designs (both domestic and Asian)...would the slotted design effect a round LD diaphragm differently than it would a ribbon element?...
 
kidvybes said:
...interesting point Phil...the grill design seems to be derivative of the current stream of ribbon microphone designs (both domestic and Asian)...would the slotted design effect a round LD diaphragm differently than it would a ribbon element?...

I don't recall any modern ribbons with anything but wire mesh. Can you give an example? Vintage ribbon mics with a slotted design often had a thin fabric backing.

Ribbons have a different curve entirely anyway. They generally are not very flat. LDC's are usually pretty flat. If you want to ensure an open, accurate sound, would you want to sing through the grill of an Austin Healey?
 
Well there's this;

http://cgi.ebay.com/SE-Electronics-...360637561QQcategoryZ41466QQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem

and this;

http://cgi.ebay.com/Western-Electri...393714933QQcategoryZ64449QQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem

and this as well. :)

http://cgi.ebay.com/EH-R1-Russian-R...393402512QQcategoryZ41466QQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem

I've not heard any of them but I wouldn't pass judgement based on their apperance as I'm pretty sure no one else would either. If anyone has used any of the above ribbon mics I'd like to hear your opinion. :)
 
Last edited:
ljmaxx said:
Well there's this;
http://cgi.ebay.com/EH-R1-Russian-R...393402512QQcategoryZ41466QQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem

I've not heard any of them but I wouldn't pass judgement based on their apperance as I'm pretty sure no one else would either. If anyone has used any of the above ribbon mics I'd like to hear your opinion. :)

Well that EH-R1 (Oktava ML-52-02) has two issues due to that headbasket design. 1.) The narrow metal bands resonate and 2.) they create narrow band comb filtering due to standing waves that result from internal reflections

In a rec.audio.pro post dated Aug 4, 2003 ribbon mic restorer Stephen Sank said: "The most ideal ribbon mics have been those with as little solid structure as possible, with the prime example being the RCA SPX-2 lab reference mic, which had just a small motor suspended in the center of a large cloth globe."
 
MichaelJoly said:
In a rec.audio.pro post dated Aug 4, 2003 ribbon mic restorer Stephen Sank said: "The most ideal ribbon mics have been those with as little solid structure as possible, with the prime example being the RCA SPX-2 lab reference mic, which had just a small motor suspended in the center of a large cloth globe."

...try telling that to David Royer and the legions of pro engineers that use/recommend his mics...

...first impressions of the Karma K55 Tube Microphone here:
https://homerecording.com/bbs/showthread.php?t=190599
 
Last edited:
I was reading all of the stuff written myself and well it seems to me that it was a an unclear issue that was mistaken when the company was formed. Plus he came forth and owned up to it after he found out the truth himself. Now that is character and respectful.

I notices a fellow HomeRecording.comer has posted a review about one of the so called Karma microphones you should read it. Seems positive to me.


https://homerecording.com/bbs/showthread.php?t=190599

also I saw a review on Harmony Central as well that was positive even if they have it posted under a different company they need to fix that

http://www.harmony-central.com/Recording/Data/Karma_Lab/K6_Ribbon_Microphone-1.html

I am going to get a microphone as soon as my money situation allows me to buy some new equipment.
 
HellBound said:
I was reading all of the stuff written myself and well it seems to me that it was a an unclear issue that was mistaken when the company was formed. Plus he came forth and owned up to it after he found out the truth himself. Now that is character and respectful.

I notices a fellow HomeRecording.comer has posted a review about one of the so called Karma microphones you should read it. Seems positive to me.


https://homerecording.com/bbs/showthread.php?t=190599

also I saw a review on Harmony Central as well that was positive even if they have it posted under a different company they need to fix that

http://www.harmony-central.com/Recording/Data/Karma_Lab/K6_Ribbon_Microphone-1.html

I am going to get a microphone as soon as my money situation allows me to buy some new equipment.
It's convenient that you signed up specially to tell us that, isn't it! :rolleyes:

I hope people aren't buying this crap -- there's no way you could go around advertising quite specific details about your company and then come back later claiming you didn't actually know what factory they were being made in. We weren't all born yesterday, y'know.
 
well i have been searching mics and you guys are talking about karma aren't you . Only four places talking about these mics. Excuse me for stating my opinions. That is what this place is for right. OPINIONS.

If you have an issue with me signing up to state my opinion well then WTF everyone has a first post correct, or did you come from the land of many posts from the get go.
 
PhilGood said:
if you want to ensure an open, accurate sound, would you want to sing through the grill of an Austin Healey?

...missed that one first time around :p ...would that be a 3000 or a Sprite?... :rolleyes:
 
HellBound said:
I was reading all of the stuff written myself and well it seems to me that it was a an unclear issue that was mistaken when the company was formed. Plus he came forth and owned up to it after he found out the truth himself. Now that is character and respectful.

Looks to me more like Karma got screwed by a pissing match between the two former architects of SE Electronics, one of whom left SE and formed a competing company, the other of whom didn't. Each claims that they are the brains behind SE. Who is right? Probably both of them.

Either way, Karma ends up looking bad as a result of something that probably isn't dishonesty on their part, but rather on the part of their Chinese partners.

I guess you could say that Karma's a bitch....
 
Put it to rest and let the product speak.

Of course, most of you know I'm an sE fan (although I now own a CAD M9 :eek: ) and personally believe that KARMA is way "out of integrity" in it's initial advertising ploy but they have been "called on their shit" and need to deal with it.
If you read all the magazine articles on the sE company it is definitely clear that Siwei Zhou was the one who started the company, couldnt get Feilio to make mics at a level of quality acceptable to him so he started his own company to ensure a higher quality mic with the Investment$$ assistance.
From my perspective, this thing should be put to rest and let the mics speak for themselves.
Let's hear some detailed descriptive commentary or even sound clips. :rolleyes:
If they are good they are good and if they are not they are not.
Then with that info and the integrity issue, let people make their own choices.
A positive about this is that by Kidvybes getting this thing out in the open, James Young from Sonic-Distribution was able to clarify it from the sE perspective and make it clear that there is no formal nor current business connection.
Lets see how it plays out!
In the meantime, back to playing and recording music :D
Woo Woo!
 
Back
Top