Take a listen to my edited drums and tell me how they suck

[StudioMxpx]

I found some old drum tracks my brother recorded they were raw as hell and i edited them take a listen and let me know if my editing skills sucks thanks heres the link http://studiomxpx.tripod.com/ its the top doiwnload called edited drums.

 

[I M Green]

Well I didn't hear anything bad editwise. Is that two kix or a double peddle? Good job. Well played as well.
Cheers
Iain

 

[johnny5dm]

I'd say the kick's a little loud, and I'm not a huge fan of the snare tone for that type of song. Other than that... I like

 

[PhilGood]

I think it sounds good except the snare might ring a little too much. That kind of ring usually gets absorbed by other instruments. Toms might be kind of low. I'd have to hear it in the mix. Great otherwise!

Do you have the full clip?

 

[johnny5dm]

Whoops, listened to the wrong clip. Disregard my earlier comments.

Take this all with a grain of salt - I'm just getting into this myself

Overall, the playing's very steady, very accurate, and good! But it sounds kinda strange to me.

First of all, the kick drum sounds like it's in stereo? Is that right? Sounds decent, just strange.
Toms are really weak compared to the rest.
The reverb/room is a strange sound - it could work, depending on what you're going for, but I think you could do better. Also, it sounds like it's in mono, which sounds a little odd by itself (but could be fine in a mix).
Snare tone is a bit overbearing. Maybe volume, maybe some EQ cuts?

 

[StudioMxpx]

I THINK THE WHOLE MIX IS IN stereo...im not sure i was just messing with setings and plugins in wavelab...as for the snare sound im trying get that tight snare sound with reverb. any suggtions?

 

[StudioMxpx]

is it the compression sound that sounds weird?

 

[PhilGood]

...as for the snare sound im trying get that tight snare sound with reverb. any suggtions?

Then you need to tune the heads tighter. It sounds like a medium pitch. I like to crank the hell out of mine.