Share your point of view

  • Thread starter Thread starter Maya Clars
  • Start date Start date
Maya Clars

Maya Clars

Active member
Hey everyone!

1. What's the biggest mistake you hear in mixes that most beginners don't even notice?
2. Do you mix into a limiter from the beginning?
3. Do you comp vocals heavily or try to comp less?
4. Do you believe the best songs are written quickly, or do they usually require endless rewriting?
5. Do you think musicians create their best work when they're happy or when they're struggling?

___
If anyone is interested what I think about these:
Balancing instruments and vocal parts, adjusting their volume levels relative to one another, I think It happens often for people who start mixing, back in 2017, it was also my first noticeable issue when I was a beginner. As for putting a limiter on the master bus during the mixing stage, I have been doing it for about a year. I'm not trying to achieve the loudest sound, music not about loudness, but I still make it loud enough so that the volume doesn’t drop too much compared to other people’s music. When I do a vocal comp, I try to keep large segments rather than slicing up the recording so much, I feel like by doing this, I allow the vocals to sound more natural. As for writing songs quickly or slowly, I can say for sure that when a song feels forced, it shows. The more effortlessly it’s written, the more attention it attracts. I've already asked a question about "having fun" while writing music, so, I think it's very important to have fun! And the last question, I feel like musicians' best work is made when they are being truthful, when they are not trying to prove something, when they are being themselves.

I love reading your answers. There's so much experience and perspective here, and it's genuinely interesting to see how you all make music!
 
For questions 1 and 2, one useful beginner trap to check is mistaking a louder version for a better balance. Compare a short chorus with the limiter on and off at similar perceived volume; bypassing it without compensating the level is an unfair comparison. Listen specifically for whether the vocal stays clear against the snare and cymbals, and whether kick hits make the rest of the mix dip.

Mixing into a limiter can be a deliberate choice, but it helps to know what it is doing to the balance. Keep a less-limited print as a reference, rather than changing every track to chase a loud commercial master. Turn the commercial reference down to a comparable listening level. That lets you judge the balance without automatically rewarding whichever version is louder.
 
They're weird questions, Maya. I'll give you my take. My bit in CAPS
1. What's the biggest mistake you hear in mixes that most beginners don't even notice? LEAD VOX THAT IS WAY TO QUIET & THE RECORDIST'S FAVE INST TOO LOUD
2. Do you mix into a limiter from the beginning? NEVER EVER USE A LIMITER - I HAVE NEVER DONE A RECORDING IN 15 YEARS WITH ONE IN CIRCUIT
3. Do you comp vocals heavily or try to comp less? COMP WHEN IT'S NEEDED - IVE DONE IT WITH AN OPERA SINGER TOO!
4. Do you believe the best songs are written quickly, or do they usually require endless rewriting? MY OWN STUFF IS RARELY RETURNED TO - CHANGES RARE
5. Do you think musicians create their best work when they're happy or when they're struggling? YES, BOTH
 
They're weird questions, Maya. I'll give you my take. My bit in CAPS
1. What's the biggest mistake you hear in mixes that most beginners don't even notice? LEAD VOX THAT IS WAY TO QUIET & THE RECORDIST'S FAVE INST TOO LOUD
2. Do you mix into a limiter from the beginning? NEVER EVER USE A LIMITER - I HAVE NEVER DONE A RECORDING IN 15 YEARS WITH ONE IN CIRCUIT
3. Do you comp vocals heavily or try to comp less? COMP WHEN IT'S NEEDED - IVE DONE IT WITH AN OPERA SINGER TOO!
4. Do you believe the best songs are written quickly, or do they usually require endless rewriting? MY OWN STUFF IS RARELY RETURNED TO - CHANGES RARE
5. Do you think musicians create their best work when they're happy or when they're struggling? YES, BOTH
hahaha I like to answer questions and I love to ask them, this way I've learned so much, so, I'm always happy when people are willing to participate in answering :) I'm self taught in mixing, mastering, and other parts of music creation, except playing the piano (I had been studying the piano in a classical music school for 10 years), so, thank you for your answer! I'll answer to your answers haha :)

1. - This is interesting! I often find some tracks on the internet that has the lead vocal louder, so much louder than any other elements in the song. I love instruments, so, It's very crucial for me to have a balance of everything, but quiet vocals is not good either!
2. - hahaha! I started using limiter less and less, It's a pity that a lot of things are limited too hard!
5. I agree with you! I often heard people said that only when they feel sad they write music, but I also think both, and any other emotions!
 
For questions 1 and 2, one useful beginner trap to check is mistaking a louder version for a better balance. Compare a short chorus with the limiter on and off at similar perceived volume; bypassing it without compensating the level is an unfair comparison. Listen specifically for whether the vocal stays clear against the snare and cymbals, and whether kick hits make the rest of the mix dip.

Mixing into a limiter can be a deliberate choice, but it helps to know what it is doing to the balance. Keep a less-limited print as a reference, rather than changing every track to chase a loud commercial master. Turn the commercial reference down to a comparable listening level. That lets you judge the balance without automatically rewarding whichever version is louder.
This is true! Louder doesn't mean better :) Great advice!
 
I like to answer questions and I love to ask them, this way I've learned so much.
The only stupid question is the one you don't ask because you feel stupid asking.

Successful people surround themselves with people that are smarter, more knowledgeable than themselves.
 
Hey everyone!

1. What's the biggest mistake you hear in mixes that most beginners don't even notice?
2. Do you mix into a limiter from the beginning?
3. Do you comp vocals heavily or try to comp less?
4. Do you believe the best songs are written quickly, or do they usually require endless rewriting?
5. Do you think musicians create their best work when they're happy or when they're struggling?
1. Their performances. Ask me how I know :geek:
2. Nah. I'll put one on near the end when I'm getting ready to mixdown to an mp3 for checking on phones, earbuds, car, laptop etc
3. In the middle, whatever feels right.
4. Can be. But don't have to be. You might sit around with a tune for a while before you get lyrics.
5. Could be either way.

If you want more specific stuff for #1 on mixes...stuff like obvious vst drums, obvious e-drum kits, lack of low end, harshness etc. From my experience in general (again ask me how I know) the biggest problems aren't so much mixing...although sure that's part of it. The bigger problems are performance, arrangement, not being able to properly assess the quality and nature of the sounds you're recording because your ear is inexperienced and you don't understand what your headphones/ speakers are doing. I don't think mixing itself is really that hard. You need to be able to trust that what you're hearing is an accurate (as possible) representation of the true nature of the thing you're recording. I spun my wheels for many years on that single problem alone.
 
Back
Top