Let me preface by saying I don't like specialty kick drum mics. They're usually easier to get a tweaked sound on, but sometimes they're lousy at accurate sounds, and more importantly, I can't afford one-trick ponies in my mic closet.
I like
the Beyer M-88 for kick (and vocals and electric guitar and . . . you get the idea), and you can often snag these new for $200. That leaves about enough budget for a pair of MXL 603s mics for overheads, at about $80 a pop. The other cheap option is
the Behringer ECM-8000 omni's at $36 each, as you probably no from reading this forum.
Now, the one concern I'd have is that the M-88 is in some ways like an idealized SM-58, so it might be a bit close to what you're already working with. You might prefer
a Sennheiser MD-421 for variety's sake (drums, guitar, bass, great for "problem vocals"), at around $300 new, maybe $250 used. This makes you choose the Behringers for overheads if you want to stay in budget.
I'd use the 57 you already have for snare, the 58 for snare bottom if you need it, and the 4033 as a room mic if you have a spare channel.
Hope that helps
Bear