ouch that stick hurt. man this is a tough one. you're going to have to buy used stuff. let me give it a shot. i'm upping your budget to $6000.
console: used soundtracs topaz or solo,
soundcraft 600/800, maybe an used allen and heath. i know somebody who recently bought an amek tac scorpion for $1500. about $1300 for one of these. no mackie please, these consoles are all better. get 24 channels minimum.
recorder: mackie sdr24/96, $1300.
mics: akg drumpack, includes a d112 and 4 c418's. $500. maybe three '57's, $225. countryman DI $250. going to have to go cheap and get a set of matched rode n5's for overheads. $300.
used DAT deck: $300. try to get a panasonic if you can. (best low budget converters)
effects: two RNC compresser's: $350, two Kepex gates: $250, a used yamaha rev500, $200. that mid-priced Roland multi- effectsbox, i forget the model number, look it up: $300. the yamaha and roland kick the shit out of the mid-priced tc and lexicon stuff, yes i've listened to all of 'em.
monitors: ns10's $350 and Hafler power amp $300
you got about $250 leftover for cables.
options: replace the mackie sdr with a 1" eight track for the same price.
well you now got a sort of usable guitar center set-up. i could do all right with this, but can you? that is the question. of course housenubs is right and you should just go a studio.