new song to critique

  • Thread starter Thread starter rweiss
  • Start date Start date
R

rweiss

New member


low budget recording but we pulled it off - song and mixing comments appreciated.
 
Last edited:
i'm not a big fan of panned doubeled vox
and i'd turn them down
the drummer is sloppy
doubled git (in a perfect world) should be tighter

the song is pretty avarage, and fits in it's genre all to well

remember, i'm just one ass
and you can ignor me
 
I like the song. the vocal performance is good but there is something about the way the vocals sit that doesn't seem right. I thought the guitars and snare could be just a bit louder. Oh, and the hi hat was a little up front for my taste. I like the sound of the drums but like I said more snare for me please.
 
I think it sounds good! But I can see what the other poster means
about drums being tighter. I think the guitars sound good.
Mix sounds good to me. I liked the vox panned.
It was a pleasant listen! I enjoyed! ;)
 
Cool enough I suppose. I hate the kick sound, it sounds like the skin is cardboard.

Things could be tighter but overall not bad.

Whoa, this takes a dive near the end. The pitch combined with drum issues made this an early ender if you get me. ;)
 
Hey thanks for all of the replies. I reposted the song again if you want to take another listen (just messed with the volumes, nothing else) - It is a rather hard song to perform at some parts (in reference to the drums) - but I know it could be a lot tighter. Also, I mixed this and the other tracks on my surround sound computer speakers (we JUST got some studio monitors - so I'm sure the next mix will sound a lot better). Thanks again for your comments!
 
Great vocals and guitar tracks but those drums are like.....oh man... way out of time with everything else, it's really ruining the experience.

Vocal pitch issues here and there, pretty obvious at 2:00.

Fix the drum timing issues and you've got a great song.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top