Get one exactly like your last one, so you can break it better next time.
ATM75 is what I have for a headset mic. Not a fan, but not that bad of a mic. Smaller frequency response range, and higher noise floor from other equally priced mics. But I guess it depends on if you factor in the cost of a mic stand and stuff with said costs. Runs on phantom power or a single AA battery. So lots of options.