instrumental blather

  • Thread starter Thread starter BRIEFCASEMANX
  • Start date Start date
BRIEFCASEMANX

BRIEFCASEMANX

Winner chicken dinner!
I don't have any keyboards with real pianos so i had to settle with this cheese(which is actually pretty decent considering it's made from a subtractive synth and not sampled). The song is on the short side because it was made for a friend who wanted a 2 minute song for an internet video he is making. What do you think of the song and the mix?

 
Yeah, ok, turn it down all the way.

I wasn't saying stop making music...more like when someone is cracking you up and you say "stop it, you're killin me".
 
jake-owa said:
Yeah, ok, turn it down all the way.

I wasn't saying stop making music...more like when someone is cracking you up and you say "stop it, you're killin me".

Fair enough. You've won for now, I retreat to my lair for now, but I WILL STRIKE AGAIN!
 
YIKES! Sounds like a schizophrenic Casio having a panic attack! :eek:
 
MORE PLEASE MORE. Although actual reasons for why it's bad would help.
 
I like these types of songs but...

I think it would be easier to follow the composition if the instruments weren't fighting each for spectral space. Everything seems to be on top of each other frequency wise.

It's hard when you are usuing a lot of synth parts, pads, etc because so many of them are voiced heavily in the mid range.

The outro was a nice idea, I hope you develop it a little more.
 
i have that trouble because i dont want to degrade the sound of anything with EQ. And I definitely notice things masking other things I just *hope* that other people don't. I guess I just need to get over it and start chopping away.
 
I think the biggest issue with the "song" is that the drum beat is ultra choppy. Its not really something a real drummer would play for something like this. Honestly it sounds like someone who doesn't really understand rhythm/drums programmed them. Kind of like the guitarist who gets behind his drummers kit during breaks at practice and attempts to play. If you programmed it choppy on purpose for tension/chaos maybe try and tone it down some. It could be cool "maybe" for a bar or two but thats probably pushing it.
The mix is cluttered. Subtractive EQ doesn't really "degrade" the sound. If you use it properly it can help things sound alot better. You need to notch out little holes in certain freq ranges for the different parts to Pop through. As it stands right now, everything is trying to pop through the same hole at once. Trust me on this one, "People" might not know why its cluttered but the average population will be the first to call you out on less than stellar production. So I wouldn't count on anyone overlooking it, especially in a mixing clinic......
 
Wireneck said:
I think the biggest issue with the "song" is that the drum beat is ultra choppy. Its not really something a real drummer would play for something like this. Honestly it sounds like someone who doesn't really understand rhythm/drums programmed them. Kind of like the guitarist who gets behind his drummers kit during breaks at practice and attempts to play. If you programmed it choppy on purpose for tension/chaos maybe try and tone it down some. It could be cool "maybe" for a bar or two but thats probably pushing it.
The mix is cluttered. Subtractive EQ doesn't really "degrade" the sound. If you use it properly it can help things sound alot better. You need to notch out little holes in certain freq ranges for the different parts to Pop through. As it stands right now, everything is trying to pop through the same hole at once. Trust me on this one, "People" might not know why its cluttered but the average population will be the first to call you out on less than stellar production. So I wouldn't count on anyone overlooking it, especially in a mixing clinic......

Thanks dude, that's exactly what I needed. My friend said he wanted something "frantic, and weird", so this is what happened. I sent it to him and he said it was "pretty good" and he still wanted to use it even though I was pretty apologetic and told him I could write something else. I think he only really liked the part with the guitar/ending though. Thanks for being constructive.
 
Back
Top