Guitar magazines

  • Thread starter Thread starter Tadpui
  • Start date Start date
Tadpui

Tadpui

Well-known member
My nephew was doing one of those elementary school fund raisers where they sell magazine subscriptions. I was in a rare mood so I went ahead and ordered a couple of subscriptions. One of the magazines I chose was Guitar World (the other was Scientific American, since I'm getting bored with Discover magazine after about 5 years).

I haven't had a subscription to a guitar mag for about 15 years now. Back then it was Guitar For The Practicing Musician, which I think became Guitar Magazine. I was never into Guitar World for whatever reason.

So after all these years, I browsed through my first issue of a guitar mag in a decade and a half. It's funny how so much has changed yet so much has stayed the same. There's still dozens of pics of long-haired dudes with pained expressions on their faces, sweating and headbanging and what not. The faces have changed but its the same as the early 1990s. Lots of shredding-centric material that I don't care for so much. And TONS of interviews with guitarists that I've never even heard of. I've been out of the loop of shred-tastic guitarists ever since I lost interest in shredding after high school. But there are some good lessons tucked away in there, and some good gear reviews too.

As for the tabs, which is the real reason to read any guitar mag if you ask me, they're pretty passable. They seem to do a good job of keeping their tab selection diverse in each issue. This issue has a couple of songs by new bands who I've never heard of. One song in drop-C# tuning, and one by Trans-Siberian Orchestra. They put a couple of AC/DC songs in there too, but I can't imagine that too many people actually need a tablature to figure out those songs. I think it was actually more difficult to try to follow along with the tab to Hell's Bells than to just feel it out.

But the big winner was that they put Mister Crowley from Ozzy in there. Now there's a song I loved to try to play back in high school. I sat with it for a bit last night but it's been too long since I've heard the album version of that song. I'll have to listen again and see if I can't get the tab down pat on that one. Learning some new songs will be a good change, since I've been playing pretty much the same songs to myself and the crickets in my basement for a decade now.

Anybody else subscribe to any of the guitar rags? Have the issues kept your attention, or have you started to lose interest in the majority of the content in each issue? I wonder if I'll just be tossing them aside without reading them by the end of my 1-year subscription.
 
Just let my Guitar Player subscription expire. I really like Guitarist out of the UK, but the US subscription price is around $100 :eek:
 
I really only buy Guitar Player for the adds. I'm a gear whore.
I suck on guitar but I suck MY way.
I can't say that I've ever sat down and read a lesson. Interviews yes, history of a certain player yes, flavor of the week overly tattooed shred monkeys tips and tricks???No.
 
Just let my Guitar Player subscription expire. I really like Guitarist out of the UK, but the US subscription price is around $100 :eek:

That one has always been one of the best of a mixed bunch. At the current exchange rate a hundred bucks is not bad. Cost the equivalent of around 75 dollars for us UK dwellers.

On the subject as a whole I don't get any of them but read most as they are often left lying around some of the outlets I haunt or in the University library I teach at. The ones I subscribe to are the more specific trade stuff. The GAL journal being the one I await the most. Having said all that Acoustic Guitar is always a good read as is Acoustic Magazine in more general terms.
 
Fretboard Journal is one of the best damn things ever printed. It's the only guitar magazine I usually read cover to cover. I'll glance through Acoustic Guitar and Vintage Guitar, and usually I'll read a couple of their articles, but Fretboard Journal is too good to put down.

The articles are universally well written, the photographs are really good, and even the paper is nice. It's a little on the expensive side, but the quality is so much higher than other magazines that it is more than worth it. $40 gets you a four issue/one year subscription, and you will never regret it.

An example: the most recent issue has a huge article on David Lindley written by Ben Harper (they've done several artist written articles at this point), with a big side article on their equipment (and a much smaller one on Lindley's clothes); a couple of articles on Brazilian Rosewood (one on the sound/mystique, and another on the legal issues); a article with a lot of pictures about Carl C. Holzapfel's early twelve string guitars (made long before they were popular, but very cool instruments); an article on banjo great Tony Trischka; etc., etc. etc.

Other great articles have included a tribute to Ted McCarty written by Paul Reed Smith, an article on Steve Cropper, a wonderful article about Neko Case and her tenor guitar collection, and just too many others to list. It's a truly great magazine, and I HIGHLY recommend subscribing to it. A magazine this good deserves to be successful.

Oh, and the advertising is minimally invasive too. It's all in the front or back of the magazine, and there isn't that much of it. That's a big part of why it's so expensive, but it's worth it. It is one magazine that you will never just toss aside without reading. I get honestly excited when it shows up.


Light

"Cowards can never be moral."
M.K. Gandhi
 
"Minimal adds". That's a good thing??? Pictures and paper quality takes priority???
Forbid you ever start a business and need buyers to see your gear. Just sayin'..
 
"Minimal adds". That's a good thing??? Pictures and paper quality takes priority???
Forbid you ever start a business and need buyers to see your gear. Just sayin'..



They have ads, they just don't get in the way of the articles. And, unlike the last time I looked at Guitar Player, with Fretboard Journal the articles are actually more interesting than the ads.



Light

"Cowards can never be moral."
M.K. Gandhi
 
"Minimal adds". That's a good thing??? Pictures and paper quality takes priority???
Forbid you ever start a business and need buyers to see your gear. Just sayin'..

Why would someone pay $6 for a magazine and then in turn get more adds than substance? What's so cool about adds? If I pay $6 for a magazine it better have substantial articles, good writing, and lots of info in it. If I want to look at adds I get that for free everywhere else;):D


Mike
 
"Minimal adds". That's a good thing??? Pictures and paper quality takes priority???
Forbid you ever start a business and need buyers to see your gear. Just sayin'..

WTF?

That is all I can say to that.
 
I really only buy Guitar Player for the adds. I'm a gear whore.
I suck on guitar but I suck MY way.
I can't say that I've ever sat down and read a lesson. Interviews yes, history of a certain player yes, flavor of the week overly tattooed shred monkeys tips and tricks???No.

Oh. Because I didn't read that.:p
 
Ads pay the bills, and reduce the price you pay for the magazine.

But am I the only one who gets turned off by page after page of grimacing teenagers with tattoos? C'mon, guys, is there a secret "conformist union" for guitar players? Back in my day, playing a guitar meant you were an individual, not a member of the herd.

Besides that, there's as much good information on the web as in the mags, at least for an old guy like me. I've got the gear I want already, I've reached my own level of mediocrity (doesn't keep me from playing in the current production of Big River at the local state U), and when I pick up a guitar magazine I feel like I'm constantly being yelled at to subscribe, to change my style, to buy buy buy.

The gear-related magazines are even worse: sorry, I don't worship gear. Gear is nothing but a tool. And sometimes, not even that!

No thanks. I'll occasionally pick one up if it has a particularly interesting piece in it, but otherwise, no thanks.
 
Ads pay the bills, and reduce the price you pay for the magazine.

But am I the only one who gets turned off by page after page of grimacing teenagers with tattoos? C'mon, guys, is there a secret "conformist union" for guitar players? Back in my day, playing a guitar meant you were an individual, not a member of the herd.

Besides that, there's as much good information on the web as in the mags, at least for an old guy like me. I've got the gear I want already, I've reached my own level of mediocrity (doesn't keep me from playing in the current production of Big River at the local state U), and when I pick up a guitar magazine I feel like I'm constantly being yelled at to subscribe, to change my style, to buy buy buy.

The gear-related magazines are even worse: sorry, I don't worship gear. Gear is nothing but a tool. And sometimes, not even that!

No thanks. I'll occasionally pick one up if it has a particularly interesting piece in it, but otherwise, no thanks.


Everything you just wrote makes me think you would LOVE Fretboard Journal. They printed a letter from one of their readers that summed it up perfectly - a guitar magazine for adults. Get one, and then you will be screaming to all your friends to subscribe - I do. They aren't trying to get you to buy anything, they aren't trying to get you to change your style; they are just trying to entertain and inform you.



Light

"Cowards can never be moral."
M.K. Gandhi
 
Everything you just wrote makes me think you would LOVE Fretboard Journal. They printed a letter from one of their readers that summed it up perfectly - a guitar magazine for adults. Get one, and then you will be screaming to all your friends to subscribe - I do. They aren't trying to get you to buy anything, they aren't trying to get you to change your style; they are just trying to entertain and inform you.



Light

"Cowards can never be moral."
M.K. Gandhi
Thanks, Light. I'll check it out.
 
The Fretboard Journal web site looks pretty attractive. I subscribed for a year.
 
Alright, I'll take a look. I've been way underwhelmed by most guitar magazines and I hope this one is different.
 
I agree with Light. The Journal is a great read. I subscribe to Fingerstyle Guitar and Acoustic Guitar. I can't stand Guitar World any more. Seems too shred-intensive, extreme, no variety beyond metal which I'm sure is their target audience and that's fine. I subscribed to Guitar for The Practicing Musician for many years until they stopped publishing. There are so many online sources for instruction these days I see the need for magazines diminishing. YouTube must really be eating into the magazines revenues.
 
I "won" a subscription to 20th Century Guitar, by signing up for one comp. copy. I think everyone who does that, or did, wins a year's sub. Not bad- lots of ads, and they are obviously very fond of Rudy's New York Guitar Shop and a particular brand of instrument cable. A bit too fond, really- those two companies (and others) run full page ads every month AND somehow get glowing comments from the columnist, too. What a coincidence, eh? But overall, pretty good rag. No song tabs, but there is an advanced lesson every month, and I got alot from the column on playing slide. But, if they want my money next year, I will probably pass.
 
I can't remember what specific guitar magazine it was, but I received an unsolicited free issue from some guitar rag in the past year. Maybe it was Premier Guitar. I'm not sure.

It featured mostly high-end gear, and the only articles I remembered were about alternative woods with the main guys from Martin, Taylor, and Gibson in the interview. Then there was an article about these 2 brothers who run a vintage collectible guitar shop somewhere either in NYC or LA. So it was OK as far as content goes.

The one thing that struck me about the magazine was how pathetically jam-packed it was with advertisements. Waaaaaaaay beyond acceptible content-to-advertisement ratio. It was just out of control with ads. Every single page had at least some sort of ad on it. At least they were all for botique amps, effects, and guitars. And the young naked chick that is the poster girl for Toadworks pedals was OK with me :). They could just put her on every page and I'd be content with the amount of advertisements.
 
Back
Top