First Post, First Song... Love to know your thoughts

  • Thread starter Thread starter Musicious
  • Start date Start date
M

Musicious

New member
Hello all,

I'm new on the forum, heard great things. I have this tune would love to know what people think of a)the tune b)the mix.

Song is called 'More than a Number'. Here's the link.



Thanks in advance guys and gals, hope this is the first post of many.

Will.

(I hope I'm not breaking any forum rules)
 
It's an interesting figure and beginning of a tune...real narrow field, and the strange vocal. I was expecting the whole thing to come smashing out of the box it's in...real brash, spread wider, with a screaming , clear vocal...a big grunge head banging. The tune remains unchanged, though. I listened to the first cycle, and searched the the rest of the tune looking for the breakout. It never happens.

What you need to start doing is listening to the music you like, and cataloging the techniques used that keep you on-edge and interested.

For example, there's a post here called 'No Coverups here...' Listen to that tune...one of the 'techniques' the guys use is to sing the second verse an octave up...a stock arranger's trick, to pump up energy and build drama and emo. That's one thing that could help drive up the heat on your song... There are thousands of little things you can do to organize 'build' and interest. It's the same concept story writers use to keep your nose in their book. You need to learn what the tricks are in music, by thoughtful analysis of music that moves you, and apply them to things you construct. And that includes recording tricks.

The sound and music in your tune has potential. Not very interesting after the first 20 seconds, though. Think about what you hear...close you eyes and imagine what it could be. Then figure out how to make it happen. Take's a while, but you'll get there when you begin studying.

Look foreward to post II !
 
I think this gets a little bogged down in the bass for me. (Is it my speakers?) Also, the tune itself is quite dramatic and ominous but becomes a little monotonous after a minute or two. With a little more room to breathe and a little less bass, the beauty could shine through, I reckon. I don't think you have to go for verse/chorus/verse/chorus, but another melody bringing things to a climax of sorts might be nice.

intomusic
 
Yeah that's pretty boring and monotonous. The "drums" sound terrible - especially the weird fill at :18. As a basic blueprint the music is good for the verses, but this thing really needs to changeups in there. If you're gonna do a loop, at least get the choruses kicking some ass. The distorted vocals are hard to understand and frankly don't sound very good. Sorry man. :o
 
Welcome to HR!

As to More than a Number:

It's a cool demo for an idea.

Lose the random drum fill up at the beginning. There's not enough variation and dynamic range to stay interesting.

We get that you're more than a number, and that you feel too real to be a stat on a screen. It does not bear repeating sixty times.

The song needs lots more content.

The distorted vocal could be interesting.. It may be a little too much, but it's promising on the singer's voice.
 
Cool

Thanks for the input guys:

I'll keep working on this as some people do like it, I get the fact that it lacks content, and doesn't really go anywhere. I'll think about it for a while a post it again after I do the work. I can actually write 'normal' songs, this tune just represents something that was made quickly, with no real thought process. I find it difficult to take my acoustic songs and actually produce them.

I will get rid of the drum fill (which is really out of place), The bass is all over the sonic spectrum, so I'll eq that a bit and try to add more of a cresendo/climax.

GREG_L: Don't worry man, be honest, if you hate it say it, at least you gave your reasons so I can use that feedback. Thanks.


Thank you for the feedback: jeffmaher, Greg, Supercreep and Intomusic.

Now I'll go listen to other peoples music before I post again, as that seems like the right thing to do.

Cheers,

Will D.
 
I pretty much agree with the previous comments re: bass is a bit hot, vocals are a little too distorted. Sure you could have more going on but I kind of like the structure you have here along with the repetitions. If nothing else it reinforces your statement and drives home the point...Your vocals are excellent but suffer from the over produced distortion. I'd try a remix with some of the changes mentioned and see what the consensus is then... Good tune but IMO could use some tweaks...
 
Back
Top