Here's the best breakdown I'm aware of:
http://home.earthlink.net/~prof.sound/id15.html
I'd go for some 2-ply 'plasticy' batters for that kind of music, Fiberskyns are for the old farts
Hey watch it now!
Fiberskyns are great in the right situation.
Personally, for hard rock of any type, I like Pinstripes. I love the sounds of Ambassadors on toms, but just for the fact that i don't have to put anything on the heads o get the tom sound I personally like - I go with Pinstripes.
Keep in mind that the most used heads on toms are either Clear ambassdaors (for a attack) or coated ambassadors (less attack).
In the studio, thinner heads and cymbals reign supreme, because it takes less force to get "full volume" out of them, so the drummer can actually hit a little lighter.
Plus, thinner cymbals are much more musical sounding. I found that out after 10 years of playing Zildjian Z and Rock cymbals.

Also, with the thinner heads - you can jut barely tune them and get the lowest note the tom will produce. Sounds like crap to me, but it mic's up really well.
Experiment some before you guys record.
The best kick sound I've ever gotten was with a 28" kick with the heads COMPLETELY slack, and no muffling at all. I had a mic mounted inside the kick. Man it was beautiful!
My guitarist showed up and plugged in (we all played in the same room and recorded everything live) and as soon as he started playing, the front head just buzzed the hole time - it was like having a 28" snare drum just rattling away, full blast.
I found this killer kick drum sound, and he just ruined it. LOL
I was never so pissed in all my life. Man, I spent days looking for a way to get the sound I was looking for, and when i finally did, it was just wash out - but the point is I learned how to get that sound - and when I build my next studio - I will be using it for my own stuff.
Why, oh why, didn't I build a drum room.
Hahahaha
Tim