I agree the smaller shops are the way to go and I also agree with alot of what you guys said.
Brian, I agree with you 100%
And mike, I agree that maybe the bigger stores are a good way to experience the instruments 1st hand, but that's all I would ever do and then order from somewhere else. Although the smaller stores might not have the selection, they can usually get you whatever you want, and if it's a bit more, I wouldn't mind paying if it helped them stay in business (i know you said that too). But in my area, the bigger stores don't hire musicians, which is part of my gripe, they hire kids just out of school with a sales degree, and these guys know nothing. Like I said though, it used to be different.
And even with the sheet music, whatever it is, once you know what you want I think you're better off shopping elsewhere for a better deal.
Have you also noticed that they all carry the same "top namebrand" items? What's with that? Why doesn't one offer somethings different? I think because they're probably in bed with these companies to a degree. Because look at somewhere like Musictoyz.com, they have a massive selection of items you'd never find at a GC, and although most of it is boutique, harder to find stuff, I'd much rather take my chances knowing that the odds of me liking it are good because it's a quality product. And the amount of instruments on the used market is incredible, and I attribute that to people getting rid of stuff they bought at a chain store because these guys are under pressure to sell their (mostly less than desirable) inventory. And I'm not saying that there isn't cheap quality stuff, but I think chain stores are under pressure to get rid of their stuff, which is fine, but their stuff all happens to be the same (ibanez, gibson, fender, etc...), what else is someone going to buy, especially if they don't know anything different, or have nowhere else to go. I guess it's like any other monopoly. If gibson has a minimum order, the bigger stores are the only ones to afford it, so then they need to get rid of it and that's what they concentrate on pushing, and then by only giving you a few selections, you're bound to buy one of them, but I'd rather then see the chain not do business with them for a policy like that, and worry about giving us a selection rather than only giving a few and being all that's out there so we don't have the choice of something better. And for those reasons I'll take my chances either online or go to the mom&pop shops (who, now they used to have selections, but they've all been driven o.o.b. cuz people didn't realize they needed to pay a little more so that they could compete and stay in business, that's how "they" won) and spend a bit extra. And I agree about helping the economy, but when places like gibson, ibanez, etc..with the help of the big chains, make sure that they are the only economy around, then I cannot support that. To truly help the economy, we'd spend money on something other than ibanez gibson fender etc.......
Sorry about the rant, I guess I'm really feeling bitter for companies, in the business of something I love, creating this situation we're in and making it like it is.